U.S. Mint production method made cameos rare
- Published: Jun 26, 2015, 7 AM
Making Moderns column from the July 13, 2015, issue of Coin World:
A common criticism of modern coins is that they all look the same.
Modern U.S. Proof coinage fits into this framework well. New issues always have a sharp contrast between frosted design elements and mirror-like fields.
This characteristic appearance is called “cameo.”
Certification companies also recognize coins with especially strong contrast. Numismatic Guaranty Corp. labels them “Ultra Cameo” and Professional Coin Grading Service uses the term “Deep Cameo.” The majority of U.S. Proof coins made since the late 1970s fall into this category.
Coins from the early part of that decade, though, are commonly seen with little or no cameo contrast. And coins from 1971 are scarce in Ultra Cameo. Consider for example the 1971-S Washington quarter dollar.
NGC and PCGS have graded 2,629 examples in all grades. Only 119 of them are designated Ultra Cameo. A coin graded Proof 69 trades for under $30, while the record auction price for a Proof 69 Ultra Cameo quarter was set in 2007 when an example traded for $7,475 in an auction by Heritage.
The scarcity of these coins is explained by the method of Proof die manufacture employed from the 1950s into the 1970s.
Chromium-plated dies were dipped in a solution of nitric acid to etch the surface. The fields were then, in multiple steps, buffed to a shine with a diamond-dust polish.
The acid etching left on the devices created a delicate frost that wore away quickly, so only a small number of strikes produced coins with strong cameo contrast.
A change was introduced in 1971 that significantly increased the number of cameo coins produced from each die pair.
Instead of acid etching the dies, the dies were sandblasted with very fine sand. This required that the field areas of the coin be covered with masking before sandblasting, a process that added considerable labor. But the end results were worth it.
Certified populations demonstrate the effectiveness of this change. Of the 2,294 examples of Proof 1972-S quarter dollar graded by NGC and PCGS combined, over a fourth of them (591 coins) are Ultra Cameo. The change is even more dramatic for Proof 1973-S quarter dollars. Of the 3,149 coins graded, 2,494 of them, nearly 80 percent, are Ultra Cameo.
Because of their comparative abundance, the Proof 1973-S Ultra Cameo quarter dollars are valued at about 50 percent of 1972-S Ultra Cameo coins. The Proof 1972-S quarter dollar graded Proof 69 Ultra Cameo trades for around $100 and the 1973-S issues can found for under $50.
More from CoinWorld.com:
US Coins Sep 16, 2019, 7 PM
Coin World Podcast: Episode 025 — Fake It Until They Take It: Beth Deisher, 9/11 Commemoration, and coin relief
Precious Metals Sep 16, 2019, 2 PM
World Coins Sep 16, 2019, 1 PM
US Coins Sep 16, 2019, 1 PM