• Gerry Tebben

    Five Facts

    Gerald Tebben goes behind the scenes and explores many offbeat trails in bringing to the forefront the long-lost information that makes coins so special in "Coin Lore."

    View one of our blogs:
    • Counterfeits

      May 11, 2015, 14:31 PM by
      first-mint
      The first U.S. Mint building at Philadelphia.

      Counterfeits from China bedevil us, but contemporary counterfeits, especially those from the early days of the Republic delight us.

      For the next five weeks, I’m going to look at copper “cents” and “half cents” that mimic regular-issue United States coins. Some were produced possibly to fool merchants, others to provide collectors with otherwise unobtainable rarities. One was a pattern for an attempt to replace the government mint with a private one.

      For the most part these items – Can you call them coins? – are collected, by tradition, as part of the regular-issue series. In auction catalogs, many appear with the word counterfeit in quotes, denoting their special status as somewhere between Mint products and out-and-out fakes.

      Because of their indistinct status, all occupy a special spot in the hearts of collectors.

      Next: The saw-maker’s patterns


    • ?Tax on checks

      Apr 27, 2015, 15:30 PM by
      delaware-county-national-bank-check-w-2-cent-internal-revenue-stamp
      This check was issued June 17, 1865, on the Delaware County National Bank shortly after the bank converted to a national bank from a branch of the State Bank of Ohio. The check, printed during the state bank days, has the word BRANCH crossed out and NATIONAL handwritten in its place. The check bears a 2 cent Internal Revenue stamp. Image courtesy of author.

      Image courtesy of Gerald Tebben.

       With the nation at war with itself, the United States government shook every tree it could find to raise money to prosecute the Civil War. It issued paper money that was backed by nothing more than the government’s full faith and taxed everything it could.

      The newly created Internal Revenue Service taxed mortgages, bonds, contracts, bank checks and a host of other documents.

      The initial bank check tax, instituted in 1862, was 2 cents on checks drawn for $20.01 and more. Tax dodgers quickly figured out that if they wrote a bunch of $20 checks instead of one big one they could avoid the tax.

      The government wised up in 1864 and applied the tax to all checks.

      Not surprisingly, the tax didn’t disappear after the Civil War or after the Indian Wars. It didn’t go away until years after the Spanish American War.

      For decades checks bore stamps that looked much like postal stamps.  Most stamps on 19th century checks are specially issued BANK CHECK stamps. But in the early years, when the government was not able to provide enough of the special check stamps, general U.S. Internal Revenue stamps were OK. The stamps were “canceled” by being written on in ink so they could not be reused.

      Sharpies figured out they could bleach out the ink cancelations and reuse the stamps, much to the government’s consternation.

      Philatelists have studied the 19th century revenue stamps extensively, but few people collect them. Despite their great history and Civil War connection, canceled bank check stamps tend to catalog for 50 cents or less.

      For check collectors, the stamps add a bit of sparkle, but a check’s primary value comes from who signed it, what’s pictured on it, which bank it was drawn on and where it was issued.


    • Tiny tax tokens

      Apr 21, 2015, 10:57 AM by
      mississippi-sales-tax-token
      Mississippi sales tax token.

      Image courtesy of Gerald Tebben.

      Sales taxes, a regressive form of taxation enjoying new popularity among tax hikers across the country, owe their birth to the Great Depression. As income and therefore income tax receipts fell in the early 1930s, state after state turned to consumption taxes.

       A problem, though, quickly developed. While a 1 percent tax on a $1 purchase worked out to an even cent, no smaller coin was available for the tax on amounts of less than $1.

       To avoid overcharging people, 12 states – Alabama, Arizona, Colorado, Illinois, Kansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah and Washington – issued their own tokens in denominations as small as 1/10th of a cent to make change.

       The tokens – tiny in size and tiny in value – proved to be too much of a bother. Most states discontinued their usage before World War II, though Missouri tokens lasted into the early 1960s.

       The tokens tend to be simple affairs – often with just the state’s name and denomination. New Mexico’s are noteworthy in that they show a saguaro cactus. Sales tax tokens were made in fiber, plastic, aluminum, zinc and bronze and were often holed.

       The tokens are avidly sought after by a small group of collectors – many of whom are members of the American Tax Token Society. Sales tax tokens tend to be junk box material, often selling for a dime or so. Some rare varieties, though, have sold for as much as $500.

       Next: Tax on checks

       


    • ?Peter the Great’s beard tax

      Apr 15, 2015, 10:48 AM by
      russian-beard-tax-token-obv
      This 1705 beard tax token sold for $4,112 at auction in 2013. This side is termed the obverse. Image courtesy of Heritage Auctions.

      Image courtesy of Heritage Auctions.

      Taxes serve three purposes: raise money for government functions, encourage activities (such as tax credits for energy efficient furnaces) and discourage activities (think cigarette taxes.)

      In 1705, Russian Czar Peter the Great instituted a tax on beards as part of his plan to modernize and westernize his backward country.

      Peasants and clerics were exempt, but everyone else who wanted to wear a beard had to pay an annual fee and carry a medal as proof of payment.  The first medals were round affairs showing a nose, mustache and beard on one side and the imperial eagle on the reverse.  Later issues were diamond shaped and dropped the images but bore the legend, “The beard is an unnecessary burden.”

      Randolph Zander, writing in The Numismatist (“Russian Beard Tokens,” December 1948), noted: “The law provided for check-points at the entrance to towns, where officials would deny passage to any bearded person who could not produce a beard token. In addition, law enforcement agencies were enjoined to arrest and fine bewhiskered individuals on sight if they carried no beard license.”

      The tax was collected from 1705 to 1772. It was levied according to rank, topping out at 100 rubles for wealthy merchants.

      Beard tax tokens are prized by collectors, partly for their novelty and partly for their sheer ridiculousness.  They are scarce and often sell for thousands of dollars when they appear at auction.

      Next: Tiny tax tokens


    • Lady Godiva's tax protest

      Apr 8, 2015, 16:54 PM by
      lady-g
      Privately minted 1792-1794 halfpenny token issued during Great Britain’s Condor token craze depicts the legendary Lady Godiva and carries the legend PRO BONO PUBLICO as do many Condor tokens, meaning "for the public good." Lady Godiva’s ride, too, was for the public good. Image courtesy of Heritage Auctions.

      Image courtesy of Heritage Auctions.

      Seventeen a beauty queen
      She made a ride that caused a scene
      In the town

      Her long blonde hair
      Hangin' down around her knees
      All the cats who dig striptease
      Prayin' for a little breeze
      Her long blonde hair
      Falling down across her arms
      Hiding all the lady's charms
      Lady Godiva

       

      Peter and Gordon’s 1966 chart topper celebrates the world’s most famous tax protest, the fabled and likely fictitious 11th century ride of Lady Godiva, wife of Leofric, Earl of Mercia in Anglo-Saxon England.

      The story of the lady’s naked ride was first recorded in Roger of Wendover’s 13th century book Flores Historiarum or Flowers of History. Despite its title, the book is a chronicle of events not a gardening guide.

      The tale has been embellished over the centuries, but the plot remains the same: Leofric refuses Godiva’s entreaties to lower the taxes on the oppressed residents of Coventry. One day, though, Leofric gives in, saying he’ll cut taxes if she rides naked through the town at midday.

      In a report on the historic person, the BBC wrote, “The rest of the story is not documented at all, but it is said that so great was her compassion for the people of Coventry that Godiva overcame her horror of doing this. She ordered the people to remain indoors with their windows and doors barred. Loosening her long hair to cover her as a cloak, she mounted her waiting horse.

      “Then she rode through the silent streets unseen by the people, who had obeyed her command because of their respect for her.”

      Peeping Tom, the tailor who was struck blind for looking, was added to the story in the 17th century.

      Lady Godiva appeared on a privately minted 1792-1794 halfpenny token issued during Great Britain’s Condor token craze. The token, which was designed by William Mainwaring and struck by William Lutwyche, shows a not-too-pretty nude equestrian on one side along with the date and the legend PRO BONO PUBLICO, a wording with a double meaning on this piece.

      With small change in short supply, private mints struck hundreds of trade tokens, often with imaginative designs, to meet the English public’s need. The legend PRO BONO PUBLICO appears on many Condor tokens, meaning that they were struck for the public good. Lady Godiva’s ride, too, was for the public good.

      The other side of the Godiva token shows Coventry’s symbol – an elephant with a castle turret in place of a saddle – and the legend COVENTRY HALFPENNY. The edge says where it was payable and by whom.

      Circulated examples are common and generally sell for $50 or less.

      The public grew tired of the collectible tokens in 1795 as supply exceeded demand. The need for the unofficial coinage ended in 1797 when Great Britain started striking copper half pennies and pennies.

      The token series takes its name from James Condor (1761–1823) who cataloged the pieces in his 1798 book, An arrangement of Provincial Coins, tokens, and medalets issued in Great Britain, Ireland, and the colonies, within the last twenty years, from the farthing to the penny size.

      Next: Trimming the hirsute



    • Rome's insulting Jewish tax

      Mar 23, 2015, 16:56 PM by
      tebben-2-obverse
      This Extra Fine example of Nerva’s FISCI IVDAICI sestertius sold for $77,675 at a March 2012 Heritage Auctions sale.

      Images courtesy of Heritage Auctions.

      This they shall give, every one that passeth among them that are numbered, half a shekel after the shekel of the sanctuary: (a shekel is twenty gerahs:) an half shekel shall be the offering of the LORD. Exodus 30:13

       

      Before Rome conquered Judea in 70 A.D., Jews paid a tax of a silver half shekel to the temple each year. In 71 A.D., Emperor Vespasian ordered that the Jewish tax – fiscus iudaicus – continue to be collected, but for the benefit of Rome, not the destroyed temple.

      Rome’s tax collectors were brutal in their methods and despised for their profession. To determine if a man was Jewish and thus subject to the tax, tax collectors were known for ordering Jews to disrobe, often in public places.

      Historian Suetonius noted, “Besides other taxes, that on the Jews was levied with the utmost rigor, and those were prosecuted who, without publicly acknowledging that faith, yet lived as Jews, as well as those who concealed their origin and did not pay the tribute levied upon their people I recall being present in my youth when the person of a man 90 years old was examined before the procurator and a very crowded court, to see whether he was circumcised.”

      After assuming the throne in 96, the Emperor Nerva issued a sestertius – a large bronze coin about the size of a half dollar – that showed his portrait on the obverse and a palm tree on the back. The legend FISCI IVDAICI CALVMNIA SVBLATA surrounds the palm.

      The legend translates as “The insult of the Jewish tax has been removed.”

      What that means, though, is open to interpretation.

      In his Guide to Biblical Coins, David Hendin, writes, “Nerva instituted an extensive series of popular changes, one of which was the abolition of the insulting method of collecting the Jewish tax. The tax itself was not revoked, only the degrading method of collecting it. To proclaim his benevolence, Nerva ordered a coin to be issued.”

      The coin, Hendin believes, celebrates Nerva’s decision to make tax collecting less abusive.

      However, Hendin’s book also reports an alternative theory posited by David Vagi, author of Coinage and History of the Roman Empire.

      Vagi believes the Romans weren’t being nice at all.

      Rome redirected the tax from the Jew’s Jerusalem temple to Rome’s Temple of Jupiter Optimus Maximus Capitolinus. When the tax was collected for the Jews, Vagi contents, it was an “insult” to Rome. Nerva’s coin celebrates the removal of that insult.


    • ?Taxman

      Mar 13, 2015, 13:21 PM by
      george-harrison
      George Harrison visiting Gerald Ford.

      If you drive a car, I’ll tax the street.

      If you try to sit, I’ll tax your seat.

      If you get too cold I’ll tax the heat. 

      If you take a walk, I’ll tax your feet.

      George Harrison’s 1966 song was a rock 'n' roll protest against England's confiscatory 95 percent tax rate on high-income individuals, especially musicians. With April 15 fast approaching, the song is the theme of the season.

      Everything the late Beatle mentioned in his song almost 60 years ago is subject to taxation in the United States today. Sales and use taxes are levied on cars,roads, chairs, fuel and shoes. Politicians leave few stones unturned in their quest to reward campaign contributors with the stolen fruit of honest labor.

      For the next five weeks, Five Facts will look at five numismatic tax touchstones dating back to antiquity. Some are amusing. Some are titillating. Hopefully all are interesting.

      Next: Rome’s insulting Jewish tax. 

      More from CoinWorld.com:

      Low-mintage 'King of Morgan dollars' example sells for nearly $40,000

      'Older, haggard' image of Ronald Reagan chosen by Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee

      $60,000 gold coin is lost at ANA National Money Show, found and returned within hours

      Casino owner altered surfaces of coins to stem exodus as souvenirs

      2,500-year-old gold and silver coins found in U.S. college's library

      Please sign in or join to share your thoughts on this story.

      Keep up with all of CoinWorld.com's news and insights by 
      signing up for our free eNewslettersliking us on Facebook, and following us on Twitter. We're also on Instagram!


    • As seen on TV: 'Rockford Files' episode shot in real California coin store

      Feb 6, 2015, 17:35 PM by
      rockfordfiles1
      This is the exterior of American Coin Co., a real store that was used as a shooting location in the 1976 episode of The Rockford Files.

      Over five weeks, ?I’m highlighting shows from the golden age of television that featured coins in pivotal roles.

      What we've covered so far:

      No. 5: The Rockford Files, Sept. 24, 1976

      An unseen 1838-O Seated Liberty half dollar played a key part in The Rockford Files show  The Fourth Man (season 3, episode 2). Interestingly, much of the show was shot in a real coin store - American Coin Co., 12164 N. Ventra Blvd., Studio City, Calif.

      In the story, coin dealer Timson Farrell, played by actor John McMartin, is a hit man who uses his coin shop as a cover for his life of crime. His latest job is to eliminate four gangsters who were going to appear before a U.S. Senate subcommittee investigating organized crime.

      A friend of private investigator Jim Rockford becomes unwittingly involved when she recognizes Farrell at the airport returning from a Miami trip a short time after traveling to Detroit. Farrell figures he has to execute her, too.

      The killer coin dealer maintained a trip to Miami to rub out a fink gangster was actually a buying trip. He said he traveled to Miami to try to buy an 1838-0 half dollar, but was beaten out by a rival dealer.  The coin, with only a handful known, is a major rarity. In 1974, a Specimen 64 piece sold for $43,000 at auction. That same coin, now labeled a Proof 64, sold for $732,500 at a Heritage auction in 2013. Fewer than 20 1838-O branch mint proofs were struck in early 1839, ostensibly “to test a press” in the early days of the New Orleans Mint.

      Farrell’s fourth hit is thwarted when the target’s bodyguard kills him.

      American Coin Co., which was established in 1959, advertised nationally in the 1970s, offering gold Bicentennial medals to non-collectors.  Today its building is home to Dilbeck Real Estate. The coin company’s large sign, visible in the television show, remains but has been repurposed for the new tenant. In the show, the store has ashtrays on the counters, coins in two-by-twos in the display cases and books and folders along the walls.

      The episode can be watched free on Hulu.

      More from CoinWorld.com:

      2015 High Relief gold $75 coin is a misfire by the Mint on many levels

      Star Trek's Captain Kirk, USS Enterprise featured on new Perth Mint silver coins

      CCAC concurs with CFA on designs for 2015 High Relief gold coin

      Several 2015 U.S. Marshals Service commemorative coins already 'out of stock’

      'Sons of Liberty' TV mini-series misses the mark when it comes to Colonial coins

      Please sign in or join to share your thoughts on this story.

      Keep up with all of CoinWorld.com's news and insights by 
      signing up for our free eNewslettersliking us on Facebook, and following us on Twitter. We're also on Instagram!


    • As seen on TV: 'Hawaii Five-0' episode likely the most famous coin-themed show

      Jan 30, 2015, 12:22 PM by
      hawaiifive0
      An Hawaii Five-0 episode titled, The $100,000 Nickel aired on Dec. 11, 1973.

      Screenshot from YouTube.com

      Over five weeks, ?I’m highlighting shows from the golden age of television that featured coins in pivotal roles.

      What we've covered so far:

      No. 4: Hawaii Five-0, Dec. 11, 1973

      An Hawaii Five-0 episode titled, The $100,000 Nickel  is probably the most famous television show with a coin theme.  Producers built the episode (season 6, episode 14) around the Olsen specimen of the 1913 Liberty Head 5-cent piece. In late 1972 the coin was the first coin to hit $100,000. The coin, graded Proof 64 by Numismatic Guaranty Corp., sold for $3.3 million at the 2014 FUN show.

      The show opens with a forger altering a 1903 nickel to look like a 1913. The action then shifts to a courier taking a locked briefcase to the security room at the Pacific Coin Convention Coin Bourse and Auction. He takes out a box holding the coin. “It’s insured for $100,000. There are only five like it in the world,” he says. The actual coin is show full screen before it is locked in a safe.

      The action then shifts to an oceanfront park. The forger is holding the altered coin with his fingers and says, “Virtually undetectable without high magnification. I think you will find it well worth $1,000.” A killer then takes the coin in a gloved hand, places it in his pocket and pulls out a pistol. He plugs the forger and walks away.

      A con man is then hired for $10,000 to switch coins. At the coin show, the carnival slight-of-hand expert casually asks to look at the coin, which is promptly handed to him. Wearing a white glove, he picks it up and switches it out. As he’s leaving the show, an alarm sounds. The con man uses the coin to buy a 15-cent newspaper, effectively stashing the coin until he can retrieve it; only he doesn’t get back to it in time.

      The coin bounces from the vending machine to a child’s pocket to a candy store before ending up as change at a bar after the con man buys a drink.

      The coin, which is still known for its TV exposure more than 40 years later, benefited from the publicity. In 1978 Superior Galleries paid $200,000 for the coin, double its 1972 price.

      The video can be seen free at YouTube.

      Next: The Rockford Files


    • As seen on TV: Murderous coin dealer in 'Streets of San Francisco' strikes fake double eagles

      Jan 22, 2015, 10:40 AM by
      streetsofsf
      Killer coin dealer Vincent Hagopian Jr. (John Saxon) examines a freshly made counterfeit double eagle while his soon to killed associate looks on.

      YouTube.com screenshot

      Over five weeks, ?I’m highlighting shows from the golden age of television that featured coins in pivotal roles.

      What we've covered so far:


      ?No. 2: Streets of San Francisco, Feb. 1, 1973

      Actor Jamie Farr (later Klinger on MASH) is offed at the beginning of this episode of The Streets of San Francisco after smuggling blank double-eagle size gold planchets into the country. (From the Great Depression until 1975, private ownership of gold was highly restricted in the United States.)

      In A Collection of Eagles  (season 1, episode 18) murderous coin dealer Vincent Hagopian Jr. uses the planchets to strike fake double eagles, including a 1907 Ultra High Relief, in the basement of his coin shop in Maiden Lane off San Francisco’s Union Square.

      Hagopian, played by veteran character actor John Saxon, strikes his counterfeits on a small screw press after hand-engraving the dies himself. He’s careful not to leave any “hair lines,” which he says are telltale casting flaws, on his fakes. His plan is to substitute the counterfeits for real coins in a 40-coin collection that his late father, an honest coin dealer, had built for client John R. James.

      The episode has several shots of James’ collection, but no close ups of individual coins. James, according to the story, had purchased the 1907 coin for $22,500 in 1962. With about 15 known, the coin remains a rarity today, often topping $2 million when it appears at auction.

      After killing yet another of his accomplices, Hagopian makes the switch. Later he’s captured after a fight at his coin store and the attempted murder of one more associate.

      At the end, collector James sends a pair of uncirculated 1882 Morgan dollars to detectives Mike Stone (Karl Malden) and Steve Keller (Michael Douglas) as a thank you. Keller looks them up in A Guide Book of United States Coins and says, “We’re rich — $4 apiece.” Today, they’re $50 coins.

      It can be watched free on YouTube.

      Next: Hawaii Five-0

      More from CoinWorld.com:

      2015 Ultra High Relief 24-karat gold coin from U.S. Mint to carry $75 denomination

      Error allows U.S. Mint customers to order and receive Proof 2015-S U.S. Marshals Service half dollars early

      2015 American Eagle silver bullion coins being struck only at West Point Mint currently

      All 2015 Kennedy half dollars to bear 1964 obverse design sculpt employed on 2014 50th Anniversary coins

      ANACS reports first example of Missing Edge Devices error for Enhanced Uncirculated 2014-D Native American dollar

      Please sign in or join to share your thoughts on this story.

      Keep up with all of CoinWorld.com's news and insights by signing up for our free eNewslettersliking us on Facebook, and following us on Twitter. We're also on Instagram!