World Coins

Collectors detect differences in coins after RCM shifts

The Royal Canadian Mint struck its Uncirculated annual coin set at the Winnipeg Mint this year, after striking the coins in Ottawa for most previous years. The coins are different in quality, often notably, as seen here on the $2 coin. Left to right, a 2010 example from an Uncirculated set appears with a 2010 example pulled from a circulation roll, side-by-side with a 2011 Uncirculated set example.

Coins loaned for photography by GatewestCoin.com.

Canadian coins being sold in an annual Uncirculated set might meet the definition of “Uncirculated,” but the standard of quality is quite different from the coins in the 2010 sets.

A Royal Canadian Mint spokesperson has confirmed that the 2011 Uncirculated set coins were struck at the Winnipeg Mint, after such sets were produced (mostly) at the Ottawa Mint in previous years, including in 2010.

The Winnipeg-struck coins are apparently struck to a different quality than those struck at the Ottawa Mint.

Cameron Giesbrecht, with Gatewest Coin Ltd. in Winnipeg, said the difference in quality is obvious. “It looks like they struck circulating coins and stuck them in pliofilm.”

Joseph Iorio of J & M Coins and Jewellry Ltd., in Vancouver, British Columbia, agreed with Giesbrecht’s assessment of strike quality.

“They don’t seem to have the mirror finish like they usually do,” he said.

Collectors have noticed the change, Giesbrecht said. “Several of our customers have contacted us to question the quality of the sets this year,” he said. “Several sets have been returned, but overall most customers have been satisfied with the sets.”

RCM Senior Manager of Communications Alex Reeves said moving production to the Winnipeg Mint was necessary to “manage record demand for our bullion products while continuing to meet production commitments for numismatic coins.”

The switch in production facility actually began with a Special Edition Uncirculated set issued late in 2010 and featuring circulating commemorative 25-cent and $1 coins instead of the Caribou and Loon designs, respectively.

“Like the 2011 Set, the 2010 Special Edition Set coins were from Winnipeg and are by definition uncirculated coins,” Reeves said.

A visual inspection of two example sets, a 2010 Uncirculated set and a 2011 set, confirms the change in quality, though it is not noticeable to the same degree on each coin.

Even on those coins that are harder to distinguish between versions, the clarity of design details is often a key identifier.

The differences in the coins’ appearance first came to notice in the hobby in the March 1 to 14 issue of Canadian Coin News, which reported dealer and collector reaction to the quality of coins in the sets. ¦


Community Comments