US Coins

Coins that make big money

A recent Wall Street Journal article on the rare coin market showcased the 1913 Liberty Head 5-cent piece as a coin with a great story. In 2010, the “Hawaii Five-O” example, graded Proof 64, realized $3,737,500 at auction.

Images courtesy of HeritageAuctions.com.

A story titled “The Coins that Make Big Money” that appeared in the Sept. 15 to 16 weekend edition of the Wall Street Journal tried to put a dollar value on the rare coin industry.

Its guess: $5 billion a year.

Although no sources are cited that were used to justify that number, the point was made clear — that the rare coin is not just a cute little hobby; rather, it is a substantial industry.

The article cited several names that are well-known to the rare coin market and noted the current separation between the top of the market — rare, six-figure coins — and the rest of the coin market.

Some big-money rarities like the 1804 Draped Bust silver dollar and the 1933 Saint-Gaudens gold $20 double eagle were mentioned. The allure of these types of coins was described as a mixture of rarity, beauty and interesting stories.

Three famed pieces were illustrated: a 1907 Saint-Gaudens, Ultra High Relief, double eagle, a 1913 Liberty Head 5-cent coin and a gold 1787 Brasher doubloon with the designer’s EB punch mark on the eagle’s breast.

Heritage Auctions President Greg Rohan noted in the article that numismatic rarities have held their value and even increased in price in recent years because of the scarcity of buying opportunities. A collector who needs a rarity to complete a set may never get a chance to buy it again.

The article cited a figure provided by Numismatic Guaranty Corp. that in 2011, the top 100 rare coins sold at public auction brought an average of $204,355, or 27 percent more than 2010.

There seems to be smooth sailing at the top of the rare coin market.

Yet, the article pointed out weakness at the core of the rare coin market, citing dealer John Albanese in noting that, “the price of more ordinary coins — the bulk of the rare coin market valued between $500 and $10,000 each — fell about 20 percent with the economic downturn.”

Many coin collectors would balk at the concept of a $10,000 coin being called “ordinary” and one could consider coins at the $50 to $500 level to be at the heart of the rare coin market.

These may not be “The Coins that Make Big Money,” but they are the gateway coins that pique interest in rare coins and plant the seeds that lead to many bigger purchases. Buying opportunities for these types of coins are much more frequent than for rarities.


Community Comments