A new die marriage has been attributed for the 1822 Capped Bust
quarter dollar, bringing the number of known varieties for the date
and denomination to three.
Corp. authenticated, attributed and graded the coin About Good 3.
The variety is cataloged as Browning 3, following the system set forth
in Ard W. Browning’s seminal 1925 reference, Early Quarter Dollars
of the United States 1796–1838.
The discovery coin was submitted to NGC by its Illinois owner at a
show after the collector initially contacted Heritage Auctions.
Connect with Coin World:
up for our free eNewsletter
Like us on
us on Twitter
The collector sent photos of his coin to Heritage President Greg
Rohan, who shared them with senior numismatist Mark Borckardt and
cataloger John Sculley.
Lowest mintage American Eagle, a counterfeit
1902-O Morgan dollar struck to circulate:
Another column in the July 10 Coin World examines a “ghostly”
Kennedy half dollar
Heritage officials advised that the collector meet with NGC’s
director of numismatic research, David W. Lange. Lange examined the
coin before acceptance for certification, and it was submitted along
with other coins.
The unidentified collector has not disclosed his plans for the coin,
according to Heritage and NGC officials.
According to NGC, “The subject coin is worn in a pattern that
suggests the dies were not perfectly aligned.”
The coin exhibits a small planchet lamination on the obverse at the
8 o’clock position.
According to NGC, the newly attributed 1822 B-3 discovery coin
marries Obverse 1 for 1822 with Reverse T, a die used to strike the
single known varieties of 1823 and 1824 Capped Bust quarter dollars,
as well as the 1825 B-1 and 1828 B-2 coins.
According to NGC officials, “Reverse T is easily identified by its
broken upper arrow shaft and lower arrow head. This same die state is
seen on the scarce 1823/2 quarters, but the die was subsequently
repaired before use with the three later dates. These 1824/2, 1825 and
1828 quarters reveal an engraving scratch from the lower arrow head
that attests to its repair.
Die marriage 1822 B-1, according to NGC, combines Obverse 1 and
Reverse R (in Browning’s book the reverse dies are lettered
sequentially from coins dated 1815 onward).
Die marriage 1822 B-2 employs the same Obverse 1, but in combination
with Reverse S, which was also used on the 1828 B-3 coin.
Numismatists still attribute early quarter dollars by Browning
numbers despite the 2008 publication of Early United States
Quarters 1796–1838 by Steve M. Tompkins, and Early Quarter
Dollars of the United States Mint 1796-1838 by Rory R. Rea,
Glenn Peterson, Bradley S. Karoleff and John J. Kovach Jr. in 2010.
Karoleff says the discovery of what is now attributed as B-3 will
get collectors to examine more closely any 1822 Capped Bust quarter
dollars they may have in their collection that could possibly also be
a B-3 coin.
Many collectors first look at the reverse of 1822 quarter dollars,
Karoleff said, to see if it was struck with the blundered die showing
the denomination reading 25/50c, which in
Coin World’s Coin
Values is listed at $5,500 in Good 4.
Karoleff said many collectors then disregard the possibility they
may have something new after determining the reverse is not the
blundered die variety.
While the B-3 quarter dollar is a marriage of two previously known
dies, the B-3 coin is only the 97th die marriage discovered among Bust
quarter dollars dated 1796 through 1838, Karoleff said.
In comparison, the Bust half dollar series, issued with much higher
mintages, has 453 identified die marriages.
Additional research needs to be conducted to determine the emission
sequence for the use of dies for the 1822 quarter dollars, which will
likely require the discovery of a second example of the B-3 coin in a
much higher grade than AG-3 to properly clarify die characteristics,
Karoleff values the currently lone known B-3 1822 quarter in excess