Detecting Counterfeits column from Aug. 8, 2016, Weekly issue of
The counterfeit 1906 Coronet gold $5 half eagle illustrated here is
a typical gold fake. The quality of this counterfeit is good, but this
type of fake is not extremely deceptive once you know what to look for.
While the piece exhibits no obvious patches of tool marks or large
repeating depressions on the coin, other diagnostics can be used to
detect this fake and most of its “cousins.”
The weight and gold content of this style of counterfeit is a good
news/bad news situation.
Connect with Coin World:
They are almost always the correct weight, diameter and thickness,
and contain the same amount of gold as a genuine coin. This means that
using measurements will do you no good when determining authenticity
(the bad news), but if you get stuck with one of these $5
counterfeits, you at least end up with approximately one-quarter ounce
of gold (the good news).
This fake was produced by transferring the details from a genuine
1906 half eagle to a set of counterfeit dies. The genuine model coin
most likely graded About Uncirculated 53.
We know this by inspecting the high points of the counterfeit —
there is a minor loss of details on all the high points, even though
the counterfeit is fully lustrous.
This is a good diagnostic for all U.S. gold — if the coin has the
luster and surfaces of a Mint State example, but the high point detail
of an Extremely Fine to AU coin, you should take a closer, much more
Other things to look for on this type of counterfeit are unusual
color and luster; tiny raised lumps on the devices and in the fields,
especially where the fields meet the raised devices; and an overall
loss of finer details.
On this fake, you can see a number of tiny raised dots on the back
of Liberty’s neck, and in the field area just to the right of her
neck. You will need a quality magnifier and good lighting to see these
diagnostics, and many collectors will need a genuine comparison coin
to see the differences.