This the latest installment in a series by Steve Roach about the
Peace dollar from the October 2015 issue of Coin World Monthly.
De Francisci’s Peace dollar design shows parallels to his other
work. The use of visible sun rays is a motif that he used in many
designs, including those he prepared for the 1938 Jefferson 5-cent
competition that he lost to Felix Schlag.
De Francisci was born in Palermo, Italy, in 1887 and moved to New
York City in 1903, studying at the Art Students League with James
Earle Fraser. He learned his craft as a studio assistant to Fraser,
MacNeil and Weinman and supported his commissioned work with teaching
at Columbia University, among other places.
The Peace dollar has a unique place in de Francisci’s oeuvre. His
medallic work overwhelmingly reflects the commissions he received at
the time, which often required formal, profile portraits of
middle-aged and older men. His Peace dollar, however, shaped later
coin designs, as Cornelius Vermeule wrote in his 1970s opus
Numismatic Art in America, “The slick modern aura, a soft
and worn look to the obverse even before the coin had circulated,
paved the way for many similar experiences in the commemorative
coinage between the two World Wars.”
Vermeule was not particularly fond of the obverse, calling it weak,
“Because an element of prettiness permeates the head of Liberty — an
emptiness of face, an elaborateness of hair, and an overall glossiness
that adds up to nothing beyond the thick rays, the meaningless locks
out behind, and a vapid lower jaw.”
Contemporary critics were more fond of the design, with Vermeule
citing one contemporary newspaper review that wrote, “The young woman
who has been adorning silver currency for many years has never looked
better than in the ‘cartwheel,’ which the Philadelphia Mint has just
started to turn out. The young lady, moreover, has lost her Greek
profile. Hellenic beauty seems to have suggested divine wisdom,
courage, ardor and serene confidence in the triumph of freedom.” Yet,
that review ended by suggesting that Liberty lacked gravitas.
Throughout his life de Francisci stated that his wife served as a
model, although Vermeule concluded, “Whether the graceful profile of
Mrs. De Francisci, or indeed, any pretty young lady’s face was needed
to create the proper sculptural mood is a point that will always
remain open to speculation.” Surely the comparisons flattered his
wife, who looks gorgeous on the Peace dollar, in stark contrast to de
Francisci’s 1920 large bas relief depicting a full-length
representation of his wife, in a fashionable sporting outfit and head
wrap, looking at the viewer.
A comparison of the facing head on the 1920 bas relief and the 1921
Peace dollar leaves little doubt as to which visual representation of
herself Mrs. de Francisci likely preferred.