The first of seven planned auctions of Dallas numismatist D. Brent
Pogue’s now legendary collection kicked off in New York City on May
19. The auction of 128 coins, held by Stack’s Bowers Galleries in
conjunction with Sotheby’s and titled “Masterpieces of United States
Coinage: Part 1,” took place at Sotheby’s headquarters on the Upper
In a panel discussion prior to the sale with Q. David Bowers, David
Tripp and Lawrence Stack, moderator Christine Karstedt asked just what
makes the Pogue Collection so special. Stack said that while Pogue was
a student of numismatics and had the resources to buy exceptional
coins, he also took advantage of opportunities in the marketplace.
Tripp praised Pogue’s “uncompromising quality standard” and his
collecting endurance, remembering a young Pogue bidding at the 1982
auction featuring gold coins from Louis E. Eliasberg Sr. collection,
where Pogue purchased his 1822 Capped Bust $5 half eagle for $687,500.
Tripp then said that Pogue should be etched into a Mount Rushmore of
READ: When is the next Pogue Collection sale?
Immediately before the sale, Bowers took the podium and told the
audience that 50 years from now people will continue to ask, what was
it like to be at the first Pogue sale? The collection in total is
estimated to bring more than $200 million and many of the greatest
rarities — including two 1804 Draped Bust dollars and the 1822 Capped
Bust $5 gold half eagle — will be in future sales.
That’s not to say that this sale lacked marquee rarities.
The first lot of the 128 coins offered was a 1792 Flowing Hair half disme graded Mint State
64 by Professional Coin Grading Service. The catalog provenance notes
that it was offered in two previous auctions within the last decade: a
July 2005 Heritage auction (then housed in a Numismatic Guaranty Corp.
MS-63 holder) where it sold for $316,250 and then at a January 2008
Heritage sale where it was offered as part of the Madison Collection
(in a PCGS MS-63 holder) and brought $503,125. Pogue purchased the
coin from dealer Larry Hanks on Aug. 11, 2010, and on May 19 it sold
for a bid of $375,000 (including the 17.5 percent buyer’s fee
the total came to $440,625), comfortably exceeding the pre-sale
estimate of $250,000 to $350,000.
The next lot, a gorgeous 1794 Flowing Half half dime graded Specimen 67
by PCGS was last offered publicly as part of Heritage’s October 2012
sale of the Greensboro Collection where it brought $367,775. As
Stack’s Bowers notes, the coin carries several layers of significance
as “a first-year half dime of the Flowing Hair type that represents
the birth of the denomination and the design type as coined within the
It is the only example to have been recognized as a Specimen
striking by PCGS. The description explains, “While many early strikes
show some level of reflectivity, this coin displays purposeful
polishing of the planchet that reflects both planning and a high level
of interest of this particular specimen’s aesthetics from before the
die faces met its surfaces.” Carrying a pre-sale estimate of $350,000
to $450,000, the handsome half dime opened at a bid of $240,000 and
sold to a floor bid of $260,000 for a total price of $305,000.
More from CoinWorld.com:
completed, Waterloo medal design considered a masterpiece
Currency Signature Auction realizes major bids
than half of March of Dimes coin sales tied to Special Silver Set
always controversial: Are we closer to replacing Andrew Jackson on
the $20 note with a woman?
Value: Eisenhower Dollar
Keep up with all of CoinWorld.com's news and insights by
up for our free eNewsletters,
liking us on Facebook
us on Twitter
. We're also on