In 1883, the Kingdom of Hawaii authorized the production of a
set of silver coins, intended to ease the coin shortage on the islands.
These coins were designed by Charles Barber of the U.S. Mint, and
struck at the San Francisco Mint. Each coin featured a portrait of
King Kalahaua I on the obverse, with the Hawaiian motto and the
denomination on the reverse.
While the dime (or umi keneta) had the lowest original mintage of
the four coins struck for circulation, it had the highest usage rate
with the Hawaiian people, and had the fewest number melted when these
coins were redeemed 20 years later. Many of the ONE DIME pieces were
made into jewelry over the years, also assisting with their survival
rate. The Hawaii 1883 dime is fairly reasonably priced, with undamaged
coins in the Fine to Extremely Fine range selling for $50 to $250.
At the current price of silver, the fabrication cost for a 90
percent silver dime blank is about $1.25, so there is an obvious
counterfeiting incentive. Fake pieces like the one shown here are
offered online, at flea markets, and other venues, usually at bargain
prices to entice collectors.
Fortunately, diagnostics for this fake are fairly easy to spot. A
raised lump appears on the king’s mustache, and several raised lumps
are in the field between the king’s chin and the II of HAWAII. The
details are slightly rough and ragged, but without a genuine coin to
compare to, this diagnostic is harder for the average collector to
detect. The weight, diameter and thickness were all identical to a
If the coin is not sealed in a holder that obscures the edge, be
sure to closely inspect the edge reeding on a Hawaii 1883 dime you are
considering buying. A genuine coin has fine, even edge reeding that is
very similar to a Barber dime, while this fake has coarse, uneven
reeding that is much too sharp for a circulation coin. I did a quick
count of the edge reeding — a genuine example has 124 reeds, while the
fake had 83 reeds. If you line up a genuine coin next to this fake,
the differences are obvious.
Collectors need to focus on the edge reeding diagnostic, and not
just for this particular fake.
More from CoinWorld.com:
Francisco moving on from group's plan to renovate Old Mint
value of United States Treasury-owned gold tops $11 billion
Kennedy half dollar came along amid circulating coin shortage in U.S.
Collection total prices realized could exceed $200 million by 2017
Analysis: Recent price declines make popular classic commemorative
Keep up with all of CoinWorld.com's news and insights by
up for our free eNewsletters
liking us on Facebook
us on Twitter
. We're also on