A newly confirmed doubled die obverse for a 1919 Winged Liberty Head
dime has the specialty collecting community excited.
The coin shows strong doubling on portions of the letters of the
motto IN GOD WE TRUST, with no apparent doubling visible elsewhere on
the two examples verified as of Feb. 24. The doubling on the coin is
strikingly similar to that on the famed 1916 Indian Head, Doubled Die
Obverse 5-cent coin, a variety that brings six-figure prices in high grade.
Experts believe that the two early 20th century doubled die
varieties were produced in the same way. A complete obverse design was
hubbed over an incomplete obverse design, with a misalignment
occurring between the partial and complete designs.
Only a portion of the motto was formed on the dime die during the
first hubbing operation, that being the tops of the letters. When the
hub used to create this obverse die was repositioned for a second
hubbing, the tops of the letters in the motto were in a different
location than on the partially formed motto on the die.
While new doubled die varieties are discovered in older series
fairly routinely, many of those finds do not necessarily draw the
attention of the variety collecting community in the way that the
newly confirmed dime variety has. That may be attributed to several
points, including the strong degree of separation between the doubled
letters on the coin; the similarity of the coin to the rare and very
expensive 1916 5-cent coin; and the relative paucity of early doubled
die varieties in the Winged Liberty Head or “Mercury” dime series.
According to a listing of doubled die varieties for the series,
maintained by James Wiles and updated on March 9, 2014, the earliest
previously known (by date on the coin) doubled die variety for the
series appears on a 1928-S Winged Liberty Head dime. Wiles lists
several dozen doubled die obverse and doubled die reverse varieties
for the series between 1928 and 1945, but none with an earlier date.
Location of the doubling
Tom DeLorey, a die variety expert who is a former grader and
authenticator for ANACS and author of the Collectors’ Clearinghouse
column for Coin World in the mid-1970s, described the location
of the doubling in a press release sent to news publications in the
collecting community. He writes: “On this new die the doubling is
confined to the upper right portion of the motto IN GOD WE TRUST,
taking in all of the letters in ‘GOD’ and ‘UST’ plus the upper right
corners of the ‘N’ of IN and the ‘R’ of TRUST. The dot between IN and
GOD is also doubled.”
Doubling is visible nowhere else on the discovery specimen and,
DeLorey added, “the lack of additional doubling was subsequently
verified on a higher grade coin.
Discovered and rediscovered
The 1919 Winged Liberty Head, Doubled Die Obverse dime was
“co-discovered by New York state collectors Scott Kerr and Jeffrey
Sam,” DeLorey writes.
According to DeLorey, Kerr apparently discovered the coin in the
1980s, but set it aside with other variety and error coins in his
“Neat Box” and did not publish the variety.
In January, Kerr and Sam, friends from their memberships in a local
coin club, reached a deal in which Kerr sold Sam his “Neat Box” of
errors and varieties. Subsequently, Sam took photos of the doubling on
the 1919 dime and some of the other coins in the collection, and began
publishing them online at a collector forum hosted by Professional
Coin Grading Service.
According to DeLorey, the dime was “dismissed by one forum member as
displaying simple mechanical doubling, and by another as being a
counterfeit coin. Nobody acknowledged it as a doubled die error.”
On Feb. 8, DeLorey said, Sam published the images of the dime on the
Numismatic Guaranty Corp. U.S. Coins forum, where DeLorey then saw the
photos for the first time. DeLorey recognized the coin as a doubled
die and immediately noticed the resemblance to the 1916 Indian Head
5-cent coin variety that exhibits similar die doubling.
DeLorey writes, “At my suggestion Jeff Sam sent the coin to Bill
Fivaz for verification, and Fivaz confirmed that it is indeed the
result of a doubled working die and not machine doubling or some other
type of striking error.”
Fivaz and co-author J.T. Stanton plan to list the new discovery as
“FS-101 for that date” in the next edition of Volume 2 of their
Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties.
DeLorey adds, “As of this writing only one additional specimen of
this doubled die has been discovered, by coin dealer John Hodson of
Munster, Ind. He saw a notification of the new variety that I posted
on the coin dealer network Coinnet, and went through his inventory and
found a high grade piece. That piece has also been examined by Fivaz
and declared to be a true Doubled Die error, confirming the
attribution of the Discovery Specimen.”
DeLorey grades the discovery coin as Fine; the second piece to be
discovered apparently grades Extremely Fine.
It is too soon to determine a possible value for the new variety.
The similar 1916 Indian Head, DDO 5-cent coin brings healthy prices in
the marketplace, with well-circulated examples selling for $5,000 or
so, and Mint State examples selling for a quarter of a million dollars
More from CoinWorld.com:
prospector unearths 87-ounce nugget in Australia
Winged Liberty Head dime has doubled die obverse, earliest in
'Mercury' dime series
Baltimore time capsule believed to contain coins
mint goes global with groundbreaking coin shape
to return to a premium to gold later in 2015
to share your thoughts on this story.
with all of CoinWorld.com's news and insights by
signing up for our free eNewsletters
liking us on Facebook
following us on Twitter
. We're also on