I’m enclosing pictures of two items I’ve owned for many years and
I’m curious about their background or history.
The first piece is a Panama Canal commemorative medal. It is my
understanding there were 50,000 of these struck and were on the first
ship to transit the canal.
The second is a U.S. half dollar sized 1864 Abraham Lincoln
The first piece appears to be a bronze Panama Canal completion
medal from 1914. According to So-Called Dollars by Harold E.
Hibler and Charles V. Kappen, “On Aug. 3, 1914 Panama Railroad
Steamship Cristobal completed first ocean-to-ocean passage through
Canal and carried 50,000 of these medals, consecutively numbered,
representing entire issue.” Mr. Liggett’s piece is serial numbered 13458.
Though the SS Cristobal was the first to cross the newly opened
passage, the SS Ancon, made the first “official” ceremonial crossing
on Aug. 15.
So-Called Dollars lists the medal with the classification
HK 398 and calls the medal “quite scarce.”
Heritage Auction Galleries recently sold two examples graded Mint
State 65 by Numismatic Guaranty Corp. One sold in a March 11, 2012,
sale for $373.75; the other sold for $575 on Feb. 5.
Mr. Liggett’s medal, if deemed authentic by an expert, would
likely sell for somewhat less at auction, as it appears to display
some circulation wear.
Regarding Mr. Liggett’s second piece, it appears to be a brass
medalet. The obverse features a right-facing portrait of Lincoln with
the legend ABRAHAM LINCOLN FOR PRESIDENT and the date 1864. The
reverse features the legend US on its center, surrounded by an eagle,
flags and staffs, cannon, cannon balls and olive branches.
A listing for this piece (classified as AL 1864-10) can be found
in Edmund B. Sullivan’s American Political Badges and Medalets,
1789-1892. The medalet was struck in three compositions —
copper-nickel silvered brass, brass and white metal. All are 31
millimeters in diameter, just a hair larger than a U.S. half dollar.
As for its potential value, a brass example, described as “Choice
virtually Uncirculated,” sold in a Nov. 12, 2004, Heritage auction for
$184. A holed, circulated silvered brass piece sold for $71.70 in a
July 14, 2006, Heritage sale.
A note in Sullivan’s book states that this medalet was a companion
piece to a George McClellan medalet (GMcC 1864-17) and a Ulysses S.
Grant medalet (USG 1864-1).
Coin World’s Readers Ask department does not accept coins
or other items for examination without prior permission from staff
member Erik Martin. Readers Ask also does not examine error or variety
coins. Materials sent to Readers Ask without prior permission will be
returned unexamined. Please address all Readers Ask inquiries to firstname.lastname@example.org or call
(800) 673-8311, Ext. 274.