This month, we are featuring four different die varieties from four
different Coin World readers. Despite significant
differences, they have one thing in common, and that is extreme rarity.
Submitted by Tony Russo, a Proof 1959 Franklin, Doubled Die
Reverse half dollar exhibits a spread toward the center on UNITED
STATES OF AMERICA, E PLURIBUS UNUM and the eagle’s talons, tail
feathers, and lower left wing feathers.
I have this one listed as 1959 50¢ Pr WDDR-001. The variety is
illustrated in Treasure Hunting Franklin and Kennedy Half Dollar
Doubled Dies, a book I co-authored with Kevin Flynn. Now here’s
the exciting part. Proof reverse dies for half dollars are used to
strike about 3,000 coins before being retired from use, so it is
highly unlikely more than 3,000 examples of this variety exist, making
it extremely rare.
William R. Hostutler submitted a Proof 1964 Lincoln, Doubled Die
Reverse cent with a counterclockwise spread on the designer’s
initials, the right base of the Memorial, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
ONE CENT and E PLURIBUS UNUM. I have it listed as 1964 1¢ Pr WDDR-053
and since it was struck by Proof dies, it too has an estimated mintage
of about 3,000 coins.
A Proof 1964 Kennedy half dollar, submitted by Dennis Fisher, was
struck by an obverse die that was quadrupled. Four close images spread
toward the center show on the letters of IN GOD WE TRUST, the date,
the ERTY of LIBERTY and the hair details on the back of the head.
Listed as 1964 50¢ Pr WDDO-028, it can boast an estimated mintage of
2,500 coins making it even scarcer than the first two varieties illustrated.
Topping things off for this month is an example of the Proof
1970-S Roosevelt dime that is missing the S Mint mark. The coin was
submitted by Don Boutsisomphone and as a Proof dime variety it has a
probable mintage of 2,500 coins. The March 2012 issue of the Coin
World “U.S. Coin Values” guide puts this one at $1,000 for Proof
65 examples and $1,200 for Proof 67 pieces. Sweet!
John Wexler is a renowned numismatic researcher and author on
error coins and die varieties.