The 1909-S Indian Head cent is one of the key dates in the series.
With a mintage of only 309,000 pieces, it is scarce enough to command
prices in Coin Values of $700 in Very Fine 20, $900 in About
Uncirculated 50 and $1,400 in Mint State 63. With these prices, it is
no wonder that the 1909-S Indian Head cent has attracted the attention
of counterfeiters and alteration experts.
At one point, the majority of fake 1909-S Indian Head cents were
simply added S alterations. Recently we have been seeing more
die-struck counterfeits of this issue. The coin shown here is a good
example of a fake struck from transfer dies.
Transfer dies employ fairly sophisticated manufacturing
techniques, where all of the details of a genuine coin are
“transferred” to a set of counterfeit dies. Coins produced using fake
transfer dies are usually quite deceptive, capable of deceiving even
Since these fake dies were produced from a genuine 1909-S Indian
Head cent, the design details and the lettering will all be correct on
pieces they strike. Many recent fakes coming from Asia can be spotted
by their crude, hand-cut date digits — this counterfeit does not have
this easy diagnostic. The S Mint mark is the same size, style and
location as on a genuine cent. We need to focus on the finer details
to detect this type of fake.
The first diagnostic area to check is the date. Under
magnification, minor doubling can be seen at the bases of the first
two digits in the date. No genuine 1909-S Indian Head cents exhibit
this type of doubling on the date digits, making this immediately suspicious.
The second pickup point for this counterfeit is the area between
the top of the D in UNITED and the rim. A small incuse line connects
the center of the top of the D to the rim. The bottom edge of this
incuse line is a tiny raised ridge that helps to define it. This line
was most likely a small scratch on the genuine coin that was used to
make the fake transfer dies, and it appears on every example of this
counterfeit. It is a tiny defect, so you will need to use a magnifier
and proper lighting to pick it up.
Most examples of this fake appear to be AU with no luster,
although they do possess a realistic chocolate brown color. Collectors
mulling the purchase of a 1909-S Indian Head cent should look closely
at these two areas. This counterfeit is one of at least a dozen
different fake 1909-S Indian Head cents that ANACS has seen over the
years, so if the coin you are inspecting does not show these
diagnostics, it is not proof that the coin is genuine.
Michael Fahey is a senior numismatist at ANACS in Denver, Colo.