Early Quarter Dollars of the United States Mint 1796-1838
by Rory R. Rea, Glenn Peterson, Bradley S. Karoleff and John J. Kovach
Jr. is one of those rare books that is both a great catalog and a
wonderful collection of stories.
First the catalog part. Every variety and many die states of early
quarter dollars are listed, described and photographed.
The photos, mostly by Rea, are big, bright and clear. Identifying
details are blown up. A tiny but important die crack from an olive
leaf to a dentil on an 1820 Browning 2 quarter dollar (The Early
Quarters of the United States, by A.W. Browning) is enlarged to
an easily seen eighth of an inch in one photo. And the quality of the
printing is so good that the photo stands up well to inspection with a
The book, which took more than a decade to produce, lists a
condition census of top coins for each variety and a bar chart showing
those coins by grade. For some rare varieties, every known coin is photographed.
The census was compiled by Rea and “seasoned quarter specialists”
Jim Koenings and Aram Haroutunian and is a delight to read in itself.
(The Browning plate coin for the 1806 B-3 quarter dollar, an About
Uncirculated piece, sold for the grand sum of $18 at auction by the
New Netherlands Coin Co. in 1952.)
If there is a right way to produce a catalog, this is it.
The 388-page, large-format, hardbound book, too, has some great
stories to tell. Probably none is so interesting, though, as that of
A.W. Browning, himself.
In a biographical introduction by Carl R. Herkowitz, Browning’s
life is teased out from the records of a mental hospital, the census
and the 1925 ANA membership.
The American Numismatic Association list gives Browning’s address
as Box 539, Central Islip, N.Y. The 1920 Census lists Ard W. Browning
as a resident employee of the Central Islip State Hospital.
Payroll records show he was a “stenographer.” Herkowitz notes that
the author of what numismatic researcher Walter Breen described as
“the most perfect numismatic book written on the first try” died from
pneumonia on May 20, 1933.
In the book, Karoleff, a fellow Coin World columnist,
also details several theories about the mysterious e and l
counterstamped quarter dollars of 1815 and 1825. The counterstamps,
which some believe were stamped on the coins at the Mint while still
in the die, flooded the market in 1882. Where they came from and why
they were made remains unknown.
The book is available for $110, post paid, from Karoleff, 8077B
Connector Drive, Florence, KY 41042. A $500 deluxe leather-bound
edition with additional plates is planned for later this year.
Gerald Tebben is an editor for the Columbus (Ohio) Dispatch.