US Coins

Philadelphia ANA show auctions exceed $80 million

The official auctions of the American Numismatic Association World’s Fair of Money held Aug. 14 to 18 in Philadelphia as co-auctioneers Stack’s Bowers Galleries and Heritage each sold more than $40 million in numismatic objects during their various ANA auction sessions. 

The top lot of the ANA auctions was in Stack’s Bowers’ Aug. 15 Rarities Night sale, where the finest known 1913 Liberty Head 5-cent coin, graded Proof 66 by Professional Coin Grading Service and bearing a green Certified Acceptance Corp. sticker, realized $4.56 million. 


collecting Proof setsInside Coin World: Collecting Proof sets, odd sports and notes with no value : We preview some of the feature content exclusive to the October monthly issue of Coin World.


Stack’s Bowers sold more than $21.1 million in U.S. coins at its ANA auctions. It also saw very strong results with its paper currency sessions, led by Part II of the Joel R. Anderson Collection, where the 70 Anderson notes realized $9,652,860, including two that broke the $1 million barrier and one that came close, realizing $900,000. With the addition of the John E. Herzog Collection of U.S. Treasury Bonds and other consignments, the paper money portion of the firm’s ANA auction realized $12,294,094, with additional world and ancient coins adding to the total. 

Heritage announced a $40 million sum that represented what the auctioneer said was its largest total ANA auction since 2015. Its U.S. coin auctions brought $27,212,944, enjoying a high sell-through rate of 97.3 percent by value and 98 percent by lot. 

Heritage’s top lot was a recently discovered 1854-S Coronet gold half eagle, the fourth known from a mintage of just 268 coins, graded Extremely Fine 45 by Numismatic Guaranty Corp., that sold for $2,160,000. Heritage’s U.S. paper money auctions added nearly $2 million to the total and its ANA ancient and world coin sessions brought $9,569,221, with post-auction sales and online sessions adding to Heritage’s ANA total. 

While multimillion-dollar coins typically capture headlines after ANA, thousands of more typical U.S. coins were also traded, many bringing surprisingly strong prices. Stack’s Bowers sold a 1940 Winged Liberty Head dime at its Aug. 17 session, graded Proof 67 by PCGS with an unusual gold CAC sticker, meaning that the coin could easily be approved for a green sticker at the next grade level. The catalog observed “exceptionally vivid multicolored toning on the obverse and around the reverse periphery,” and it brought $5,040. 

The price approaches the $5,287.50 that a PCGS Proof 68 example with a green CAC sticker realized at Legend’s Oct. 26, 2017, Regency auction. For reference, a more typical, untoned example graded PCGS Proof 67 with a green CAC sticker sold recently for $242 and even typical Proof 68 examples can bring under $1,000 at auction.  

Connect with Coin World:  

Sign up for our free eNewsletter
Like us on Facebook  
Follow us on Twitter


Community Comments