'Die adjustment strike' remains a persistent,
- Published: May 13, 2011, 8 PM
For many years the writers of this column have made a conscious decision to avoid the term “die adjustment strike” when referring to an exceedingly weak (low-pressure) strike. Synonyms include “die trial,” “test strike,” “trial strike” and “setup piece.” All of these terms assume that a profoundly weak strike represents a coin that was struck as the settings of the coinage press were adjusted.
There is no doubt that die adjustment strikes have been produced through much of the Mint’s history. The word “myth” is instead directed at two common misconceptions; 1) that press adjustment is the sole or primary source of very weak strikes, and 2) that die adjustment strikes escape the Mint in numbers large enough to account for their frequent presence in the marketplace.
Weak strikes arise from two proximate causes — inadequate ram pressure and insufficient die approximation (excessive minimum die clearance). Ram pressure is the tonnage applied to a planchet of normal thickness. Die clearance refers to the closest approach the dies make to each other in the absence of a planchet.
Determining proximate cause
Determining proximate cause is often difficult; assigning ultimate cause is virtually impossible. A simple, centered weak strike could be a die adjustment strike or the product of spontaneous equipment malfunction. The latter category might encompass dies falling out of adjustment, a jam-up in the guts of the press, a mistimed or broken cam (upon which the anvil die rests), a mistimed hammer die, a slack or cracked press frame, a loose or broken knuckle joint, or a broken circuit breaker.
Numerous independent lines of evidence indicate that the vast majority of weak strikes in the marketplace are the product of spontaneous equipment malfunction, with most caused by an increase in minimum die clearance.
Absolute abundance: If weak strikes were the product of die adjustment, they should be very rare, as such test strikes are ordinarily consigned to the furnace. In truth, weak strikes are relatively common. They frequently pop up on the online auction site eBay, and the prices they command are commensurate with their ready availability. Most lower-denomination examples (cent to quarter dollar), cost $50 or less. Shown here is a recently purchased 2007 Montana quarter dollar that cost a mere $35.
Distribution by denomination: If most simple, centered weak strikes were die adjustment strikes, their relative abundance should be proportional to the total number of coins struck and dies used. Cents should therefore be the most common denomination affected by this error.
In my experience, however, the most commonly affected denomination is the dime, followed by the cent, quarter dollar and 5-cent coin. This is exactly the pattern you’d expect from weakness caused by spontaneous press malfunction resulting in insufficient die approximation. Dime planchets are quite thin, enforcing a narrow margin of error when setting the minimum die clearance. Only a slight increase in this safety margin will result in a weak strike. A slight decrease will result in a clash if a planchet is not positioned between the dies — an error that occurs on dimes with great frequency. A larger margin of error exists for thicker planchets.
This distribution pattern is also at odds with the once-popular notion that weak strikes are generated when a press is first turned on and when it’s shut off.
Occurrence with other striking errors: If weak strikes were lucky escapees from a test run, then multi-error weak strikes should be almost nonexistent. In fact, I have observed exceedingly weak strikes in association with a wide range of striking errors: off-center strike, brockaged off-center strike, double strike, triple strike, saddle strike, misaligned die error, rotated die error, clashed dies, indent, partial brockage, full brockage and struck-through. Shown here is a 1983-D Jefferson 5-cent coin with a weak second strike delivered by a rotated (30 degrees) and misaligned (35 percent) hammer die.
Multi-error weak strikes also provide a second argument against the press start-up/shut-down
Instantaneous changes of striking pressure: The die adjustment scenario is falsified by multiple strikes in which there are instantaneous changes in striking pressure between strikes.
This phenomenon is beautifully illustrated by a Washington quarter dollar struck three times by the same die pair.
The first strike was normal while the second was 40 percent off-center and exceedingly weak. The third strike was 75 percent off center and forcefully delivered. This example also illustrates the self-correcting nature of some malfunctions responsible for weak strikes.
Coin World’s Collectors’ Clearinghouse department does not accept coins or other items for examination without prior permission from News Editor William T. Gibbs. Materials sent to Clearinghouse without prior permission will be returned unexamined. Please address all Clearinghouse inquiries to email@example.com or to (800) 673-8311, Ext. 172.
US Coins Aug 14, 2020, 4 PM
US Coins Aug 14, 2020, 4 PM
US Coins Aug 14, 2020, 1 PM
US Coins Aug 11, 2020, 5 PM