A complaint filed Sept. 6 in federal court in Illinois by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission alleges
Newport Beach, California, precious metals firms and their affiliate
firms defrauded thousands of customers out of more than $290 million
from “illegal, off-exchange retail commodity transactions.”
The allegations touch on transactions involving gold, silver,
platinum and palladium from approximately 12,000 accounts between July
16, 2011, and March 2017.
The 32-page complaint names as defendants Monex Deposit Company,
Monex Credit Company, Newport Services Corporation, and the firms’
principals, Louis Carabini, and his son, Michael Carabini.
In a prepared statement Sept. 6, Monex officials denied the CFTC’s
allegations contained in the complaint.
Connect with Coin World:
up for our free eNewsletter
Like us on
us on Twitter
The CFTC complaint alleges the defendants, acting individually and
collectively, “deceptively” promoted leveraged sales through its
“Atlas” commodities trading program as “a safe, secure and profitable
way for retail customers to invest in precious metals.”
According to the complaint, approximately 90 percent of the
leveraged Atlas accounts lost money between the 2011 and 2017 dates.
Monex is alleged
to have inflated the profit potential while underrepresenting the risk
of losses, according to the complaint.
The complaint explains that the Atlas program is structured in such
a way “that customer losses are all but inevitable,” losses from which
Monex stands to gain, through “outsized price spreads, commissions,
interest on loans, and administrative fees.”
“To take just one example, Monex price spreads for a single trade
can be 100 times larger than price spreads for a similar trade on a
regulated exchange,” according to the complaint.
During the specified period from which the CFTC’s allegations are
rendered, Monex executed approximately 140,000 trades from the
Monex permits Atlas account holders to trade “on leverage” or “on
margin,” with Monex helping to finance a portion of its customers’
During the 2011 to 2017 time frame addressed in the complaint, some
3,000 accounts received a margin call, with at least 1,850 trading
A margin call is a demand by a broker, in this case, Monex, that an
investor deposit further cash or securities to cover possible losses.
An Atlas account was subject to force liquidations by Monex if the
account equity dropped below 7 percent of the total originally established.
Monex’s Atlas program criteria allowed for margin requirements to be
changed at any time and for an account to be liquidated at any time at
The CFTC is seeking a preliminary injunction to prohibit Monex from
continuing to market the Atlas program to retail customers, and
appointment of a monitor over Monex for the Atlas trading accounts.
The preliminary injunction would prohibit Monex from trading,
soliciting orders, committing fraud, or engaging in business activity
related to contracts or transactions regulated by the CFTC until there
is a final decision on the merits.
The CFTC seeks forfeiture of proceeds from the alleged fraudulent
sales, restitution for the benefit of defrauded pool participants,
civil monetary penalties, permanent registration and trading bans, and
a permanent injunction from future violations of federal commodities laws.
The complaint identifies a number of specific cases involving Atlas
➤ A 61-year-old Charlotte, North Carolina, woman invested $173,500
from the $400,000 she received from her son’s government-issued
insurance policy after he was killed while serving with the U.S.
military in Iraq. Almost her entire investment was lost.
➤ A 77-year-old Texas man invested his and his wife’s entire life
savings of $400,000. In April 2013, the client received back only
$8,900 from his investment.
➤ A 54-year-old Newport Beach, California, woman invested her entire
$1 million in retirement savings in August 2013. Within 18 months, the
Atlas account lost $760,000 from the initial investment.