Counterfeit Proof American Eagle and American Buffalo 1-ounce gold
$50 coins have been reported in Ohio encapsulated in fake Numismatic Guaranty
Corp. plastic holders with counterfeit grading label inserts.
The counterfeits surfaced in the greater Columbus area at a retail
coin shop whose owner wishes to remain anonymous.
The dealer reported March 21 that a customer came into his store a
few days earlier to sell a purported NGC-certified 2014-W American
Eagle 1-ounce gold coin. While the piece initially appeared like any
other Proof American Eagle, further examination showed that the
encapsulated coin, while exhibiting Proof surfaces, was missing the W
Mint mark of the West Point Mint.
Connect with Coin World:
The grade on the grading label insert also designates the coin's
condition as MS70, for Mint State 70, a grade that would not apply to
a Proof coin. The MS-70 grade would apply either to a bullion coin,
struck properly with no Mint mark, or to the Mint's Uncirculated
version, often termed Burnished Uncirculated, which is marketed to
collectors and carries a W Mint mark.
The dealer checked the certification number of the questioned piece
on the NGC website. The certification number on the
counterfeited gold piece is registered to a genuine NGC MS-70
Burnished Uncirculated 2014-W American Eagle $50 coin.
When the dealer compared the diagnostics on the suspicious coin
against a known genuine example in his inventory, he determined that
some design elements on the suspect coin were incomplete, including
detail on the eagle feathers. The dealer also determined the suspect
coin and holder together weighed 10 grams lighter than what a genuine
coin in its encapsulation would weigh.
Get our free report: What to Know Before Investing in Bullion
The dealer also determined that a purported Proof 2011-W American
Buffalo 1-ounce gold coin that the same customer brought in was also
counterfeit, along with its holder and grading label insert.
Max Spiegel, vice president of sales and marketing for NGC's parent
company, Certified Collectibles Group, said the grading service has
previously encountered similar counterfeits.
"We've seen these on occasion," Spiegel said March 21 via
email. "Both the coins and holder parts are counterfeit. The
quality of these counterfeits is generally quite poor. For example,
the $50 Gold Eagle is labeled MS 70 but looks like a PF coin (and does
not appear to have a 'W' Mint mark).
"We encourage people to always check the Verify NGC
Certification feature on our website (https://www.ngccoin.com/certlookup/). Since
October 2008 we have imaged nearly all of the coins that we have
graded as a measure against counterfeiting and tampering. You can
compare a potential purchase to these images to make sure that they
match. In the case of the images you sent, they do not match the ones
we have available on our website.
"If a legitimate NGC certification number is copied on a
counterfeit holder (or if there is some other issue related to that
certification number) we will put a note 'Contact NGC Customer
Service' in our Verify NGC Certification tool to advise a prospective
buyer that they should contact NGC Customer Service.
"We are researching both the origins of these counterfeit
holders as well as enhanced security features for our holders.
Counterfeit holders not only infringe upon our registered trademarks,
but also violate the Hobby Protection Act of 1973 and the Collectible
Coin Protection Act of 2014. We will consider all available options to
pursue those who counterfeit our holders."