The Reverse Proof 2013-W American Buffalo gold coin was a hot
commodity Aug. 13 at the U.S. Mint’s booth at the American Numismatic
Association convention in Rosemont, Ill., with three dealers acquiring
more than half of the coins through surrogates.
A long line formed at the United States Mint booth during the
opening day of the ANA World’s Fair of Money in the Chicago suburb.
Exhausting the Mint’s supply of 1,000 Reverse Proof American Buffalo
1-ounce gold $50 coins took approximately five hours.
The sales represented the first opportunity for collectors and
dealers to buy the coins and have the pieces immediately in hand. The
U.S. Mint began offering the coins for sale via its website at
www.usmint.gov and by telephone at 800-872-6468 at noon Eastern
Daylight Time Aug. 8, but coins were not being shipped as of Aug. 13.
Each customer in line at the U.S. Mint’s booth on the convention
bourse was permitted to buy a maximum of five of the .9999 fine gold
coins, at a price of $1,640 per coin. Most of those in line took
advantage of the maximum, paying out a total of $8,200 for a five-coin allotment.
Acting U.S. Mint Director Richard A. Peterson tantalized show
attendees by displaying one of the coins in its highly polished wood
presentation case during remarks he gave before the show’s opening.
U.S. Mint officials announced through the numismatic press the week
before the convention that the bureau planned to have a quantity of
the Reverse Proof gold coins for sale at the show.
A line of coin dealers and their representatives had already
formed in front of the Mint booth before the show’s official opening
to the public, and the line continued to grow as more collectors and
dealers sought to obtain the coins. Because of the quick sellout of
the 1,000 coins, Peterson arranged for another 1,000 coins to be
delivered to the convention center, expected to arrive for sale by
Friday, Aug. 16.
SilverTowne from Winchester, Ind., managed to secure nearly half
of the 1,000 coins the Mint sold Aug. 13, by offering a bounty of $100
per coin to those who obtained the coins. The firm expected to acquire
about 400 coins from its sources buying the coins at the show.
SilverTowne’s president, David Hendrickson, said the firm would be
submitting the coins to Numismatic Guaranty Corp. for certification.
Hendrickson said any coins certified Proof 70 were expected to be
immediately offered for $2,995 each via the Coin Vault cable
John Maben from Modern Coin Mart in Sarasota, Fla., said he was
able to purchase between 100 and 110 coins. He initially paid a
premium of $50 per coin, then bumped the premium up to $75 and then to
$100. Maben divided the number of coins he purchased evenly between
Professional Coin Grading Service and NGC for certification.
Maben said he expected to offer the coins through his retail
business at a price in the lower range from $2,000 and $3,000 per coin
for those pieces graded Proof 70.
Lee Minshull from Lee Minshull Rare Coins Inc. in Palos Verdes
Peninsula, Calif., said he purchased 100 to 150 coins at a premium of
a little over $100 per coin. Minshull said Aug. 14 he had not yet
received the results of grading submissions, which he had evenly
divided between PCGS and NGC.
Minshull added that he was frustrated by the Mint’s handling of
the sales. He said he had wired the Mint “considerable funds” for a
substantial number of coins through the normal sales process when they
went on sale Aug. 8. His frustration resulted from the Mint’s not
immediately shipping the coins ordered earlier, but having only a
small number of the coins at the show available for direct purchase.
As of 5 p.m. Eastern Time Aug. 1, the Mint had sold 29,453 of the
Reverse Proof American Buffalo gold coins through its various sales
venues, according to a sales meter updated daily at the Mint website. ■