As I write these words I reflect on November 1962, when super-rare
Mint State 1903-O Morgan dollars — cataloging for $1,500 in the “Red
Book” (A Guide Book of United States Coins by R.S. Yeoman)
with none higher — were discovered by the hundreds of thousands! I had
never seen such excitement, nor had anyone else. Up to that time I had
never seen a Mint State 1903-O Morgan dollar, and few others had either.
The story goes back to 1929 when many bags of old O-Mint dollars
were shipped from the New Orleans Mint to the Philadelphia Mint and
sealed in a special vault, so they would not have to be counted at
regular intervals. In time, the coins were forgotten.
In 1962, the Federal Reserve requested that the Philadelphia Mint
ship some “new” dollars out for distribution as holiday gifts. Most on
hand were bags of mixed circulated dollars. Then someone thought of
the sealed vault. It was opened, and presto! The numismatic market
I was front row center in a lot of the action as it developed and
enjoyed it immensely. I began a decade of interviewing dealers and
others who were participants and recording their experiences to be
included in my Silver Dollars and Trade Dollars of the United
States: A Complete Encyclopedia, published in two volumes in 1993.
The sparkling nice-as-when-minted 1903-O dollars set off a silver
rush all across America.
Banks and Treasury Department holdings were tapped. Eventually,
hundreds of millions of long-stored dates and Mint marks came to light
— mostly in the Morgan series. I learned that there was only one coin
among circulation issues that was not found: the 1895-O dollar. Of all
the others, at least some were discovered, including some of the key
1893-S dollar and millions of some others.
Harry J. Forman, of Philadelphia, was the leading dealer in sealed
bags of dollars, wholesaling them nationwide. The sealed vault in
Philadelphia still contained countless 1,000-coin bags of dollars, and
elsewhere in storage in the Mint were innumerable other bags of such
coins. Most had no markings as to their contents.
Ever-innovative, Harry came up with the idea of paying vault
custodians a tip if they would go into the vaults, smoking cigarettes
— which was allowed at the time. They were to press the lighted end
against the cloth of a bag, create a hole near the top, shake the bag,
and find out the date and Mint within. This worked like a charm, and
he got his first pick of scarce and rare varieties, while common coins
Q. David Bowers is chairman emeritus of Stack’s Bowers Galleries
and numismatic director of Whitman Publishing LLC. He can be reached
at his private email, firstname.lastname@example.org,
or at Q. David Bowers LLC, Box 1804, Wolfeboro, NH 03894.