Possibly everything you ever wanted to know about the silver
American Eagle — one of the most widely collected modern U.S. coins —
is now packaged in a single reference co-authored by the U.S. Mint
sculptor-engraver who designed and sculptured the coin’s reverse.
To be officially released Nov. 20 by Whitman Publishing LLC,
American Silver Eagles — A Guide to the U.S. Bullion Coin
Program, represents the culmination of a 36-year career by John
M. Mercanti as a member of the U.S. Mint’s engraving staff at the
The book was written by Mercanti, with Michael “Miles” Standish,
senior grader at Professional Coin Grading Service. The foreword in
the 8.5-inch by 11-inch, 168-page hardcover book is by Michael Reagan,
son of President Ronald Reagan, under whose presidential
administration the American Eagle silver bullion coin was first
introduced to collectors and investors in November 1986.
President Reagan signed the enabling legislation into law in July 1985.
Since the American Eagle silver bullion coin’s November 1986
introduction, collectors and investors have purchased more than 326.6
million silver American Eagles combined in bullion, Proof, Reverse
Proof and Uncirculated versions.
Mercanti and Standish are scheduled to be attending the Whitman
Baltimore Expo, Nov. 15 to 18, to help promote the book.
The two writers, according to Whitman, “bring together diverse
elements — technical and artistic, historical and current,
market-driven and hobbyist — to make American Silver Eagles a valuable
addition to any numismatic bookshelf.”
Mercanti told Coin World that he considers the reference
a “living book” that will require periodic updates as additional
information becomes available.
A long career with the Mint
Mercanti, who spent 46 years total as a federal government
employee, joined the U.S. Mint’s engraving staff in 1974. Mercanti was
hired by U.S. Mint Chief Engraver Frank Gasparro, who quickly became
Mercanti’s mentor, and ultimately, a close friend.
The American Eagle silver bullion coin was authorized July 9,
1985, under Title II of Public Law 99-61 — as The Liberty Coin Act. It
was an amendment to the legislation authorizing the Statue of
Liberty-Ellis Island commemorative coins.
The American Eagle silver bullion coin is codified in the United
States Code as 31 U.S.C. § 5112(e)-(h).
Eagle design for the reverse of the American Eagle silver bullion coin
was approved by Treasury Secretary James A. Baker III after review by
the Commission of Fine Arts. The winning design was selected from
submissions to an open design competition.
Mercanti retired from the U.S. Mint on Dec. 30, 2011, with the
title of chief engraver. The title was bestowed upon Mercanti in
February 2009 by then U.S. Mint Director Edmund C. Moy. The
presidentially appointed position of chief engraver had been
eliminated under Mint reform legislation in 1996, but Moy resurrected
the title for Mercanti.
From 2006, with his naming as supervisory design and master
tooling development specialist, up to and including his naming as
chief engraver, Mercanti was responsible for supervising the Mint’s
engraving staff, technicians, engineers and others.
During this period, Mercanti guided the output of the nation’s
coinage from sketch to finished production, as well as any tweaking
necessary in the steps between.
Mercanti’s tenure as a member of the U.S. Mint’s engraving staff
is eclipsed only by Mint engravers George T. Morgan at 48 years,
William Barber at 47 years, and Gasparro, Mercanti’s mentor, at 39 years.
Mercanti is credited with 26 noncirculating commemorative coin
designs, five State quarter dollar designs, and four American Eagle
bullion coin designs, in addition to more than 35 U.S. Mint medal designs.
The new book’s opening chapter follows the obstacles the United
States Mint faced as it entered the world’s bullion coin market.
Mercanti contributes behind-the-scenes history of the silver
American Eagle, its design development, the minting process, and other
elements of the coinage series.
The book features a detailed date-by-date study, plus varieties
and sets, with high-resolution photographs, rarity information,
values, certified-coin populations, surface and strike
characteristics, market details, packaging information, issue prices
Among the book’s contents are details about special American Eagle
➤ Proof 1995-W coin — the first Mint-marked Proof silver American
Eagle struck at the West Point Mint, included as a bonus coin in a
special five-coin set also containing four Proof American Eagle gold
coins from the tenth-ounce size through the 1-ounce coin.
➤ Uncirculated 2006-W coin — the first issue with a special
burnished finish, and included in the 2006 20th Anniversary Silver
Eagle set and 2006-W 20th Anniversary Gold and Silver set.
➤ Uncirculated 2008-W Reverse of 2007 coin — bearing a reverse of
the 2007 style rather than the revised 2008 design. The difference is
easiest seen at the U in UNITED, with the variant bearing the
lettering style of 1986 to 2007, without a downstroke or stem (called
a “spur or foot” in the book) at the right, while the style intended
for 2008 as the Mint moved to digital sculpturing, and which appears
on the Proof version, has a downstroke on the right side of the U.
➤ Reverse Proof 2011-P coin, the first silver American Eagle with
a finish exhibiting mirrored raised devices against a frosted
background, included in the special five-coin 2011 25th Anniversary
Silver Eagle set.
➤ Reverse Proof 2012-S coin, special strike from the San Francisco
Mint that was only available in the
2012 American Eagle San Francisco Two-Coin Silver Proof set.
An overview of other coins in the U.S. bullion program is also included.
The Mercanti/Standish reference also includes compiled charts for
coin-by-coin comparisons; a glossary of numismatic terms; and an index
for looking up specific information.
The book also contains eight pages of color plates illustrating
Mercanti’s other coinage and medal designs.
His own words
In American Silver Eagles — A Guide to the U.S.
Bullion Coin Program, Mercanti, in his own words, chronicles
his personal odyssey with the development and production of the silver
coin since its introduction.
Mercanti relates that the silver American Eagle obverse was
predetermined to replicate sculptor Adolph A. Weinman’s obverse design
that had been adopted for the Walking Liberty half dollar (1916 to
1947). Mercanti says he has no idea who made that decision.
Mercanti explains that for the first few years of the silver
American Eagle’s life, no modifications were made to Weinman’s obverse
design despite fill problems with metal flow, a failing that resulted
in a lack of fine details on the finished coins. Later, as technical
changes were made in the creation of designs, models, hubs and dies,
modifications were made to Weinman’s model. The Mint staff sharply
enhanced the stars in the flag, the lines in Liberty’s skirt,
Liberty’s sandals and the oak leaves, according to Mercanti, “so that
everything was as clear as we could make it at that scale.”
In the book, Mercanti explains in detail the technical changes
made to design processes during the production of the silver American
Eagle, and how those changes ultimately permit desired design tweaks
to be made.
The book can be pre-ordered for $29.95 per copy at www.whitman.com.
The book will also be available online and from bookstores and
hobby retailers nationwide beginning Nov. 20. ■