Market Analysis: 1815 Treasury note leads Heritage sale of Coltrane offering
- Published: Nov 25, 2020, 10 AM
The Heritage Auctions sale of the Mike Coltrane Collection of United States currency in Dallas on Nov. 4 and 5 offered few surprises. The 484 lots resulted in sales worth $2,598,341, including the buyer’s fee.
As expected, the leading item was the only known $3 bill issued by the United States, a Treasury note of the War of 1812. At $168,000 in a grade of Very Fine 25 by Paper Money Guaranty, it sold at the lower end of its estimated selling price.
The unusual denomination, issued under the Act of Feb. 24, 1815, was fully issued and uncanceled, with three signatures. It corresponds to Friedberg number TN-16b in Paper Money of the United States. It is from the fifth and final issue of these Treasury notes that were used as an emergency measure to raise revenue during the War with Great Britain. The first four were in denominations from $20 to $1,000. The final issue, in 1815, was in smaller denominations, from $3 to $50, which were used to pay for good and services, customs duties, and as cash reserves for banks. They are considered by many to be the first circulating American paper currency, predating the demand notes of 1861 by over four decades. The $3 note was one of 21 War of 1812 notes in the sale.
Another unique note was a Series 1875 $100 national gold bank note from the Union National Gold Bank of Oakland (California), Friedberg 1166. It was a relative bargain at $144,000 in a grade of PMG Fine 12 Net. All national gold bank notes are rare, and those from banks other than the First National Gold Bank of San Francisco are rarer still. Additionally, only eight of the $100 notes are known, for all national gold banks.
Only eight notes of all denominations are known today from the Union National Gold Bank of Oakland. The Oakland note is one of a number of notes from the Albert Grinnell collection to recently appear at auction. At the Grinnell sale in 1945, it sold for $125.
The “Net” designation in the grade is due to some restoration, but it should be understood that any national gold bank note in a grade higher than Very Good is a rare find.
A pair of 5% interest-bearing notes of the Act of March 3, 1863, sold for $90,000 and $96,000. The first was an F-197 $20 one-year note in PMG Choice Very Fine 35, a grade that ties it for the finest known. Heritage said it had not cataloged one of these since 2007. The other was a $50 two-year note, F-203, in PMG Choice Very Fine 30, also tied for the best known.
An iconic “Spread Eagle” Series 1863 $100 legal tender note in PMG Choice Very Fine 35 brought $87,000, $11,000 more than when it was last sold by the firm (to the present consignor), in 2018. This is the first note to feature the American eagle as part of the design, on which it dominates the entire left side of the obverse.
Among Treasury notes, the $100 “Watermelon notes” of the Series 1890 issue get most of the attention, leaving the $50 note somewhat underappreciated. There are 35 examples of the F-377 $100 Watermelon note in the Track and Price census, as opposed to only 22 of the F-376 $50 notes. One reason may be that the $50 note was issued only in Series 1891, where the backs are more mundane compared to the ornate lathe work on all issues of the 1890 series. Nonetheless, it is of greater rarity. The Coltrane Collection example once belonged to Amon Carter. It was in PMG Very Fine 25 and realized a respectable $87,000, the highest price ever for the grade.
MORE RELATED ARTICLES