Last week, I discussed obsolete currency issued by state-chartered
banks from 1782 to 1866. For many scarce issues — say, no more than 50
to 100 known — choice examples can be purchased inexpensively, often
for $25 to $100 each. These prices will get you notes that have been
signed in ink by the bank cashier and president, and were used in
circulation. Great rarities are often available for, say, $500 to $2,000.
Choice grades range from Fine to Extremely Fine. It is a seeming
paradox that Uncirculated bills are generally worth lesser amounts and
are not as desired! Why? Because these notes were never signed and
After many of the banks stopped paying out their bills, thousands
of notes often remained in their vaults, sometimes in uncut sheets of
four notes each. Many varieties are very common, certain bills of the
Canal Bank of New Orleans being an example. I once had a chance to buy
7,000 four-subject Uncirculated sheets for $2 each.
Another curious aspect of obsolete bank notes is that many bills
were once common, but not a single example exists today. Where did
they all go? Who knows.
At regular intervals, interesting finds surface. Often these seem
inexpensive to anyone who has grown up with rare U.S. coins, for which
a unique example might be unaffordably priced at untold thousands of
dollars. The note illustrated above from Maine cost me $1,750. I have
never seen or heard of another!
One reason that obsolete notes are so inexpensive, relatively
speaking, is that no current reference books are available. The last
to treat Maine notes was by James A. Haxby and was published 31 years ago.
If you want notes that are really inexpensive, try collecting a
series for which there are no reference books at all. Civil War scrip
notes of many different states beckon — say Massachusetts, New
Hampshire and Connecticut for starters. Of course, it takes a bit of
courage to sail into uncharted numismatic waters, but that is part of
You can always “retreat” to, say, Morgan dollars, for which there
are a dozen or more price guides, no need to learn about grading (what
with third-party graded coins), no need to do much besides write a check.
And coins are Mint State, not ragged Very Good!
How do I get started with collecting obsolete notes? Simple! Go to
the Professional Currency Dealers Association (website found at
www.rarecurrency.net/) and poke around on some of the dealers’ sites
Q. David Bowers is chairman emeritus of Stack’s Bowers Galleries
and numismatic director of Whitman Publishing LLC. He can be reached
at his private email, firstname.lastname@example.org,
or at Q. David Bowers, LLC, Box 1804, Wolfeboro, NH 03894.