This curious 41-millimeter French bronze medal bears a small
round-headed uniformed bust left wearing the star of the Légion
d’Honneur, resting on clouds over weeping willows.
Below is a dog stretched out on a grave, symbolizing ultimate
fidelity. Inscriptions note the subject’s “Good fortune and fidelity
... turn to his country and to public Admiration from the Island of
Saint Helena” in 1840.
This was the year of the Return of the Ashes, Napoleon’s body, from
his South Atlantic rock of exile to his grand tomb in the Invalides in Paris.
The name of the Frenchman depicted on the medal appears nowhere on
the piece, but he was obviously involved with Napoleon’s entombment in
France, gloriously stage-managed by Citizen-King Louis Philippe to
exploit the prevailing wave of Napoleonic nostalgia for the king’s
July Monarchy. The project began with the voyage of the king’s son the
Prince de Joinville in the warship La Belle Poule to Saint Helena.
The emperor’s body was exhumed, its coffins opened. The
well-preserved remains were identified, placed aboard ship and brought
across the Atlantic to the port of Cherbourg, then transported by
water up the Seine, thence in a sumptuous funeral procession to the
Invalides, where it was presented to the king.
Who, then is the well-deserving general on the medal? Two generals
accompanied Napoleon in 1815: Charles Tristan Marquis de Montholon and
Henri-Gratien Comte de Bertrand (1773 to 1844). Both inscribed the
emperor’s reminiscences and wrote of his life in exile, returning to
Europe only after Napoleon’s death in 1821.
Montholon was not in high repute in France because of old legal
problems involving corruption and claims of military honors he never
received. Bertrand was esteemed, having been sentenced to death in
1817 but pardoned by Louis-Philippe and sent with the Joinville expedition.
Both men figure in a conspiracy theory alleging that Napoleon died
of arsenic poisoning contrived by the British government or by French
opponents. However, modern forensic analysis of four locks of
Napoleon’s hair taken at different times in his life and locks from
his second wife and son show essentially identical amounts of arsenic.
It is probable that arsenic vapor was produced by tropical molds in
the arsenic-based Scheele’s Green wallpaper in Napoleon’s residence
Longwood, sickening his entire staff. The emperor actually died of
stomach cancer, as did his father, Carlo, and other family members.
As to identity, comparison of the features on our mystery medal with
the portrait on a 25.2-millimeter brass medalet commemorating
Bertrand’s death on Jan. 31, 1844, proves that it is Bertrand, not
Montholon, who is honored on this somewhat perplexing piece.