Universally hailed as “the coinman to Canadians” and “the dean of
Canadian numismatics,” James Edward Charlton died Sept. 20.
He was 102.
Mr. Charlton, an engineer who became a coin dealer and hobby
publisher, enjoyed a legacy matched by few if any in Canadian numismatics.
Mr. Charlton began collecting coins 87 years ago, a passion he
credited his older brother Harry for stoking by giving him an 1863
Indian Head cent.
Mr. Charlton set aside the hobby, however, when he moved to
northern Ontario in 1933 to begin working for International Nickel Co.
He worked for several companies in Ontario (including Canada’s first
nuclear energy plant) before he and his wife, Mary (whom he married
Feb. 3, 1945, and who survives him today), were ready to move south.
While the Charltons were visiting Mary’s family in their hometown
of Toronto for Christmas 1947, he saw an ad in the Toronto Daily Star
for an engineer position at the newspaper. Mr. Charlton secured the
job and he and Mary moved to Toronto. The move also rekindled his
dormant interest in coins.
Toronto had coin shops, and the local coin club provided
numismatic camaraderie that paved the way for new ventures in the hobby.
It was a rapid ascent; Mr. Charlton published his first price list
in 1949 and began mail auctions in 1950. Within four years of taking
up the hobby with zeal, Mr. Charlton had published his first catalog,
laying the foundation for modern Canadian numismatics.
Mr. Charlton ’s name is affectionately used as shorthand for a
bookcase worth of coin, paper money and token catalogs published since
he issued the first volume in 1952. The 34-page pamphlet, titled
Catalogue of Canadian Coins, Tokens & Fractional Currency, soon
morphed into the Standard Catalogue of Canadian Coins, Tokens and
Paper Money, which was later split into three catalogs by subject.
Within a decade of publishing the first catalog in 1952, Mr.
Charlton stepped down from his job at the newspaper to devote full
time to numismatics, as his coin dealership, auctions and publishing
consumed ever more time. In 1980, Mr. Charlton sold his publishing
business to William Cross.
Mr. Charlton attended the first 51 CNA conventions (from 1954
through 2004), most of the American Numismatic Association conventions
for decades, as well as hundreds of other coin shows, Mary often
During his career, Mr. Charlton owned and operated three
numismatic firms in Canada. He served as the first Coin World Canadian
Trends editor from 1961 to 1969, and again from 1983 through 1990.
In 2001, Cross published J.E. Charlton, Coinman to Canadians, a
biography by Harold Don Allen.
The book is one of many tributes to Mr. Charlton, who received the
Award of Merit gold medal from the Ontario Numismatic Association in
1967 and the J. Douglas Ferguson Award, given for distinguished
service to Canadian numismatics, in 1972. In 2004 he was honored with
the Paul Fiocca Award for meritorious service to the Canadian
Numismatic Association, which he served as vice president and president.
Fellow hobbyists have shared multiple reminiscences of Mr.
Charlton, universally praising his integrity and his willingness to
share information; many credit his catalogs as generating interest in
the coin hobby in Canada more than any other single factor.
In a letter to fellows of the Canadian Numismatic Research
Society, Scott E. Douglas said: “Suffice to say that there is scarcely
a collector in Canada and many other parts of the world that has not
heard of the Charlton name. Jim always represented himself with
dignity, honesty and integrity. ... Jim Charlton is a numismatic
legend. His legacy will live on in all who knew him.”
His son James R. Charlton, writing in an essay in the forthcoming
October issue of the RCNA Journal, said that his father “was
a simple man who took his daily life in stride. ... He was always fair
in his business dealings, saying many times that how you conducted
yourself in business was how your life really was, and in retrospect
he was right.” ■