B. Max Mehl was the impresario of the coin auction catalog.
Auctioning coins is a high cost proposition. Each auction requires a
“headline” collection, meticulous research, quality photography,
attractive design and effective promotion.
Only the largest numismatic firms, like Stack’s Bowers Galleries
or Heritage Auctions, can boast of having held hundreds of coin
auctions. For individual dealers, 50 career auctions is a significant achievement.
B. Max Mehl, a solo practitioner, held a whopping 116 auctions
between 1906 and 1955. John W. Adams, in his indispensable two-volume
United States Numismatic Literature, has examined — and graded for
quality — every auction catalog issued by every major American coin
dealer. One quarter of Mehl’s auctions earned an A-minus or better
from Adams, mainly due to the quality of the coins cataloged within.
Mehl’s consignors comprised an all-star numismatic lineup: H.O.
Granberg, James Ten Eyck, William Forrester Dunham, William Cutler
Atwater, Will Neil and even King Farouk of Egypt.
No one could showcase a numismatic collection like Max, as the
cover of “A Royal Sale,” featuring coins from King Farouk’s
collection, amply demonstrates.
The cover also exemplifies Mehl’s resourcefulness, for the king
had refused permission to use his portrait as the cover illustration,
so Mehl used an Egyptian coin featuring Farouk on the obverse!
Mehl did not auction every collection he handled; some he bought
intact and sold at fixed prices. Prime among them were the large cents
of Dr. George French and the encyclopedic collection of Waldo
Newcomer, for which Mehl paid a king’s ransom — $220,000 — in 1933,
the worst year of the Great Depression.
Max could spend lavishly because he had deep-pocketed customers
like Col. E.H.R. Green, son of the “Witch of Wall Street,” financier
Hetty Green. Mehl sent catalogs to all four of Green’s homes for six
years without a response, before finally cracking the colonel’s sales
resistance. Green’s first order was for $1,800, which proved but a
rehearsal for his second, which totaled $63,500! Remarkably, Mehl did
not conduct a single public auction; all 116 were mail-bid sales. Nor
did he enjoy doing business in person.
Mehl told The Saturday Evening Post that he welcomed visits from
his customers, entertained them royally, and enjoyed their company,
but refused to sell them coins face-to-face. He insisted on conducting
transactions by mail because “you can’t do business with people when
they come to see you ... they want to talk more than they want to buy.”
Adams notes that Mehl never became a numismatic expert. His price
list of Dr. French’s large cents was riddled with errors, and Albert
A. Grinnell was so incensed at the mistakes in the catalog when he
consigned duplicates from his legendary paper money collection that he
later chose dealer Barney Bluestone to sell his front-line bills.
Excepting the first 20, Mehl’s catalogs are relatively common, and
sell for about $25 apiece.
JOEL J. OROSZ is a charter member of the Numismatic Bibliomania
Society and co-author of The Secret History of the First U.S. Mint. He
can be reached at Joeljorosz@gmail.com.