The July 12, 2010, Collectors’ Clearinghouse focused on an odd,
10-year run of misaligned die clashes among Lincoln cents.
Carrying dates from 1991 to 2000, each of these cents features a
light die clash involving a hammer (obverse) die that was
simultaneously tilted (vertically misaligned) and horizontally
misaligned, the latter often dramatically so. Some of the coins also
feature a rotation or pivot of the hammer die.
One representative example is the illustrated 1993 Lincoln cent,
which is cataloged as MDC-1c-1993-02 on maddieclashes.com. When the
dies clashed, the hammer die was tilted down toward the southeast and
horizontally misaligned about 25% in the same direction.
The current tally of these “radical MAD clashes” is 27, with a
number of additional entries in the “possible” column.
Canadian coins affected
A smaller number of similar die clashes have now been documented
among Canadian coins by Robert (“BJ”) Neff, the driving force behind maddieclashes.com.
The earliest example appears to be a 1949 5-cent coin. A double
row of clash marks representing the dentils of the reverse die can be
found in the center of George VI’s ear. The hammer die (the reverse
die in Canadian coins) was tilted down at its southern pole and
horizontally misaligned about 50 percent toward the north at the time
of the clash. This is one of the few radical MAD clashes in which the
direction of downward tilt is opposite that of the horizontal shift.
This coin is listed as MDC-CA5c-1949-01.
1962 and 1963 cents
A small cluster of radically misaligned die clashes occurs among
Canadian cents in the years 1962 and 1963. One coin, MDC-CA1c-1962-01,
shows a single row of dentil clash marks within the oak leaf notch
farthest to the right (see photo). The hammer die was tilted down
toward the east and horizontally misaligned about 20 percent in the
Two or three misaligned die clashes co-occur with a normal,
centered die clash in MDC-CA1c-1963-01.
The normal clash mark is represented by a curved line beneath the
left lower margin of the maple leaf (white arrow). It represents Queen
Elizabeth II’s chin.
Down and to the left is a short row of dentil clash marks from the
outer margin of the anvil die face (black arrows). To the left of that
is a less complete set of dentil clash marks (red arrow). Farthest to
the left is a faint curved line that might represent the lateral
margin of the die’s rim gutter (green arrow). If that’s the case, then
the hammer die was very steeply tilted during that clash.
The last example discussed, MDC-CA1c-1963-02, shows three sets of
dentil clash marks. They are located above and to the left of the
maple leaf. The horizontal misalignment ranges from 5 to 15 percent.
At the time of the clash, the hammer die was shifted toward the
northwest and tilted down in the same direction.
A puzzling feature
One puzzling feature of both the U.S. and Canadian radical MAD
clashes involves the relationship between the direction of die tilt
and the direction of horizontal movement. In the vast majority of
cases, the directions are the same. In other words, if the hammer die
is tilted toward 4 o’clock, it also shows a lateral shift in the same direction.
Exactly the opposite trend is seen in coins actually struck by a
tilted and horizontally misaligned hammer die. In these misaligned die
errors, the direction of tilt is opposite that of the horizontal shift.
In other words, if the hammer is tilted down toward 4:00, it is
laterally shifted toward 10:00. This makes complete sense. As a die
tilts down at one pole, it tends to tilt inward at the same pole,
presuming there’s no independent lateral movement.
In the case of the radical MAD clashes, tilt and horizontal shift
are entirely decoupled. This again supports the idea that the clashes
are not taking place during a press run, but prior to or during installation.
Coin World’s Collectors’ Clearinghouse department does
not accept coins or other items for examination without prior
permission from News Editor William T. Gibbs. Materials sent to
Clearinghouse without prior permission will be returned unexamined.
Please address all Clearinghouse inquiries to firstname.lastname@example.org or to
800-673-8311, Ext. 172.