If you are a newcomer to coin collecting, you might think that all
of the great discoveries have already been made. How wrong you would be!
This was brought to mind recently in my work with John Ostendorf
and others in the Civil War Token Society on two parallel projects.
The first is my Guide Book to Civil War Tokens, now
nearing its final manuscript stages and due to be published by Whitman
The second is helping the CWTS with the third edition of Civil
War Store Cards, by George and Melvin Fuld, the last edition of
which was issued in 1975. Enough new discoveries have been made that
the third edition will likely list the best part of 1,000 that were
not known before.
Civil War tokens are a delight to study, but the field is enjoyed
by only a small percentage of collectors in America.
Among federal coins, are there opportunities to make new
discoveries? The poster example of the answer “yes” is the 1817/4
Capped Bust half dollar.
Although early half dollars had been collected and studied since
the late 19th century, this overdate variety was unknown until 1930.
E.T. Wallis from Los Angeles announced in the October 1930 issue
of The Numismatist that he had just found a new overdate, 1817/4, with
the digits boldly defined. Wallis acquired it from a family that had
held it since 1846.
In the 1934 edition of The National Catalog of U.S. Coins
(a publication long forgotten), Wallis advertised it for $2,500. Years
later it was acquired by Al Overton.
By then, it had not been listed in reference books, a frustrating
situation. In 1953, Overton sold it to Louis E. Eliasberg Sr. of
Baltimore, who had already completed his collection of known dates and
Mint marks of U.S. coins, but was glad to learn of this “new” variety.
I had the pleasure of offering the Eliasberg coin at auction in
1997, where it was graded Extremely Fine 45, the finest known, and
crossed the block at $209,000. Later, the coin changed hands a couple
of times and was sold by Stack’s in October 2006 for $310,500, which
today stands as the record.
By the time of the 2006 auction, other examples had been found.
Coin World’s Oct. 24, 2005, issue reported that another had
been found in upstate New York in a pile of fill dirt, bringing the
total to eight known. The Dec. 17, 2007, issue reported the ninth
known 1817/4, a coin recently discovered by a Colorado woman who
inherited it in a group. Today any one of the coins, typically in Very
Fine grade, is valued over $150,000.
Q. David Bowers is chairman emeritus of Stack’s Bowers Galleries
and numismatic director of Whitman Publishing LLC. He can be reached
at his private email, firstname.lastname@example.org,
or at Q. David Bowers LLC, Box 1804, Wolfeboro, NH 03894.