A fabled Australian gold rarity that sold in a Sept. 27 auction
established four records, auction house representatives believe.
The coin, a 1920-S gold sovereign from the Bentley Collection of
milled gold sovereigns, realized £780,000 (about $1,261,520 U.S.),
including the 20 percent buyer’s fee.
That is a record price for an Australian coin, according to
representatives from A.H. Baldwin & Son, which sold the second
part of the Bentley Collection during Coinex week in London.
The coin also established record prices for a British Imperial
gold sovereign, for a British Colonial coin and for a 20th century
The coin, struck at the Sydney Mint, is one of the rarest
Australian coins. It is one of four known circulation-strike examples
(a specimen Proof also exists). Three of the circulation strikes are
available for private ownership.
The auction was a high drama sale and the 1920-S sovereign was the
jewel of the Bentley Collection.
The tension mounted as lot 736 was placed on the auction block.
The piece was estimated at £300,000 to £400,000, and bidding started
with a telephone bid of £260,000 relayed via Baldwin’s director Steve
Hill. The room began to buzz.
It was later discovered that the bidder placing the first bid was
Bob Jaggard of Jaggard’s, the Sydney coin dealers, bidding on behalf
of an anonymous client. A U.S. buyer in the room came in at £270,000,
followed by a gentle ping pong of bidding with Australia versus the
United States. For the first round of bidding, Jaggard and the unnamed
American were the only bidders.
Then there was a near disaster when the line from Australia went
dead — the coin was then with the American gentleman at £340,000.
“That has never happened to me before on such a high profile
coin,” Hill said. “I shouted out ‘Hold on!’ to the auctioneer and
jabbed the redial button. It only took a few seconds to get through,
but it seemed like an age.”
The bidding between bidders in Australia and the United States
continued throughout the second half of the £300,000s. However, the
pace slowed when the £400,000 barrier was broken. Bidding then went up
in £20,000 steps.
At £440,000 the coin was with Jaggard in Australia. The American
bidder was clearly approaching his limit and asked the auctioneer if
he would accept a bid of £450,000. The auctioneer agreed. The
Australian bidder came in via Hill with £460,000.
Just as Jaggard most probably thought that after a two-bidder
contest the legendary sovereign was most likely his, a third bidder,
an Englishman, stepped into the bidding arena with a bid of £480,000.
The atmosphere in the bidding room became more intense.
The volleys between the Australian and the British bidder
continued. At £550,000 the game became a little slower, but the price
continued to rise until it was with the Englishman at £640,000. Hill
bid £650,000 on behalf of Jaggard. The Englishman declined to raise
the bid and the hammer fell. The coin was destined to return to
Australia, to Jaggard for a buyer who wishes to remain anonymous.
What makes the Sidney Mint 1920 sovereign so special?
Although record’s show 360,000 sovereigns were struck at the
Sydney Mint in 1920, how many were actually dated 1920 is a matter of conjecture.
Some researchers believe that many 1920-dated coins must have been
melted down; others think that 1919-dated coins are included in this
calendar mintage figure. Either way, collectors only began to discover
the true rarity of the coin in the second half of the 20th century.
Indeed, this same example was offered on Jaggard’s retail list in
February 1979 for $4,250 Australian (then about £2,360 or $4,720 U.S.).
In 1992, Spink sold a Good Extremely Fine example. The cataloger
noted that it was “of the highest rarity, only a few specimens known.”
Estimated at £20,000 to £25,000, it sold for £114,400 (then about
$195,200 in U.S. funds).
The Bentley Collection example was last offered at an Australian
auction April 11, 2006, when it realized a then-record of $582,500
Australian (at the time about $426,796 U.S.).
The newly record-breaking coin was struck from a rusted reverse
die (which is usual for the circulation-strike 1920-S sovereigns).
Apart from minor imperfections and light handling marks, it is
otherwise practically As Struck.
Other highlights from the second part of the Bentley Collection include:
➤ A Melbourne Mint pattern sovereign 1879, by William Wyon. It is
one of only two examples known, the other being in the Melbourne Mint
Collection. It is not illustrated in Wilson Rasmussen’s work on gold
patterns and Proofs. Apart from four tiny black spots, it is in
Brilliant Mint State. It sold for £48,000 (U.S. $77,632) against an
estimate of £12,000 to £15,000.
➤ A Proof 1931-P sovereign from the Perth Mint in Mint State and
of the highest rarity realized £52,800 (U.S. $85,395) against an
estimate of £30,000 to £40,000.
➤ A Proof 1929-M sovereign from the Melbourne Mint, “as struck and
extremely rare,” realized £40,800 (U.S. $65,897) just above the
estimate, which ranged from £30,000 to £40,000.
➤ An 1892 gold pond, single shaft variety, from South Africa, also
exceeded expectations. Described as “apart from some tiny surface
marks, otherwise as struck,” and estimated at £20,000 to £25,000, it
sold for £38,400 (U.S. $62,105).
➤ A 1926 Sydney Mint specimen sovereign, practically As Struck
(apart from a couple of minor nicks and a spot of the king’s cheek)
reached £33,600 (U.S. $54,342) against the estimate of £30,000 to £40,000.
➤ The rarest circulation strike Canadian sovereign, dated 1916,
realized £22,800 (U.S. $36,875) against a £10,000 to £12,000 estimate.
It is “as struck,” apart from some tiny light marks.
The auction totaled £2,226,104 (about $3.6 million in U.S. funds).
The final part of the Bentley Collection will be sold May 7, 2013.
The first auction, conducted May 8, realized £899,346 (about
$1,452,600 in U.S. funds). ■