Houdini medal missing edge marks poses unanswered mystery

Readers Ask column from May 18, 2015, issue of Coin World
By , Coin World
Published : 05/06/15
Text Size

I just read your article about Jewish-American Hall of Fame medals (Coin World, July 30, 2012, issue) and wondered if you might be able to tell me what I have. In 2013 I bought one half of the Harry Houdini pair and I’ve recently been fortunate enough to purchase both parts (the Houdini medal was issued with two parts opening to reveal four “sides”). 

The medals I just bought have inscriptions on the edge but my original half medal does not. The individual half weighs 73 grams and the one from the set weighs 76 grams. The individual medal (which looks different from the one from the set) seems to have a coating on it almost like a shellac. What do I have?

Debby Meister  /  Via Email

 

Mel Wacks, the creative force behind the JAHF medal program, told Coin World that he has seen individual parts sold as the whole medal.

Wacks initially suspected that Meister had a rare gold example of the medal, but a gold medal would bear edge inscriptions and weigh 55.6 grams, so that possibility was ruled out.

Wacks said that bronze versions of the Houdini medals were made at the same mint, in two separate production runs, but they should have edge markings. 

“The unmarked half seems to have narrow polish edges and polishing on the hand-cuff and key which surprises me,” Wacks wrote. “But the weight tells me this half is a bronze medal. I don’t understand why there is no edge markings.”

All JAHF medal have edge numbers, with the exception of a few patterns provided by whichever mint Wacks hired to strike the medal. Sometimes, after running out of the normal medals, Wacks would sell the pattern, which lacked any of the edge markings. 

He does not have records of selling the sample for the Houdini medal, Wacks said. 

“But that doesn’t mean I didn’t. Sometimes I keep them and sometimes I sell them. Maybe it will have to remain another Houdini mystery.”

You are signed in as:null

Please sign in or join to share your thoughts on this story

No comments yet