Newman’s ‘ordinary’ coins: 1875-S Coronet $5 half eagle a ‘filler piece’ with provenance

Portion of Market Analysis column from Dec. 8, 2014, issue of Coin World
By , Coin World
Published : 11/24/14
Text Size

The following post is pulled from Coin World editor Steve Roach’s Market Analysis column in the Dec. 8 issue.

A collection as extensive as St. Louis numismatist Eric P. Newman’s has more than its share of top-tier rarities, but it also contains many other coins that are more ordinary. Heritage’s recent Nov. 14 and 15 auctions for the Eric P. Newman Numismatic Educational Society provided collectors a chance to buy a coin with a sensational provenance, at little or no premium to what an unnamed coin might bring. 

The coin: 1875-S Coronet $5 half eagle, VF-25

The price:
$1,292.50

The story:
 Collectors who think that famous collections have only top-quality coins need only look at this example to see how even great collectors have coins that may be described as a filler piece.

This 1875-S Coronet $5 half eagle graded Very Fine 25 by Numismatic Guaranty Corp. brought $1,292.50. It’s a scarce issue, with a low mintage of 9,000 pieces, of which an estimated 100 to 150 are known today. Heritage notes that “this example is moderately abraded but displays lively, medium-gold surfaces and surprising amount of underlying flash.”

While comparables are scarce at auction for a thinly traded issue like this in an unusual grade, this piece sold for what may have been expected, considering that Heritage sold an example graded NGC VF-20 in 2011 for $1,035, and last year Heritage auctioned one graded Extremely Fine 40 for $2,585. That the Newman piece brought slightly more than the VF-20 piece while selling for less than the EF-40 piece could be expected, even with the bonus of a Newman provenance.

Read the rest of Steve Roach's market analysis:

Popular 1923-D Saint-Gaudens $20 double eagle bought without ’substantial premium'

A Newman Collection Indian Head cent sold for only $42?

More from CoinWorld.com:

Artist reimagines Lincoln cent with portrait of Ronald Reagan

A Newman Collection Indian Head cent sold for only $42?: Newman’s ‘ordinary’ coins

2014 First Spouse gold coin sales well below maximum authorized mintages

U.S. note that flew in space with John Glenn sells for $11,250 during Nov. 12 Heritage auction

2015 50-penny coin honors Battle of Britain’s 75th anniversary

Keep up with all of CoinWorld.com's news and insights by signing up for our free eNewslettersliking us on Facebook, and following us on Twitter. We're also on Instagram!

You are signed in as:null

Please sign in or join to share your thoughts on this story

No comments yet