Sometimes this writer gets schooled. Such a schooling just happened
after last month’s column discussing the mysterious disappearance of
all large paper copies of Numisgraphics, Emmanuel Joseph Attinelli’s
indispensable bibliography of numismatic auction catalogs.
I correctly wrote that 10 large, paper copies of Numisgraphics
were produced in 1876. I also correctly wrote that Attinelli still had
four large, paper copies left to sell in 1878 when he cataloged the
C.W. Idell sale.
But then I incorrectly wrote that all 10 copies had vanished
immediately afterwards. It was John W. Adams who proved me wrong. And
there is no better teacher to give you a schooling about numismatic literature.
When Quarterman Publications reprinted Numisgraphics in 1976, it
asked Adams to write the foreword and to provide a rarity and
valuation guide to the catalogs listed within.
Numisgraphics covered only those catalogs published prior to 1876;
so Adams finished the job Attinelli started, writing United States
Numismatic Literature Volume One (covering the 19th century), and a
second volume (covering the 20th century), which have become the
numismatic catalog collectors’ “bibles.”
For each of the major catalogers, Adams lists the names and dates
of their sales; the consignors; number of lots; a description of the
contents; and a letter grade for overall quantity. Trying to collect
American coin auction catalogs without Adams’ two books is like trying
to collect U.S. coins without Coin World’s Guide to U.S. Coins
Prices & Value Trends.
So what did he know that I didn’t? Not all large, paper copies
disappeared from the face of the earth after the Idell sale in 1878,
for Adams discovered that, at the height of the Great Depression, coin
dealer Thomas Elder sold one. Elder was a genuine piece of work.
Numismatically knowledgeable, fearless and outspoken, Elder also
possessed a temper as explosive as nitroglycerin.
If Elder liked you, he was a fierce friend; if he disliked you
(and he disliked many), he was just plain fierce. It is one of the
great ironies of numismatics that after he retired from the coin
trade, Elder moved from New York City to an upstate town named Pleasantville.
In Elder’s 242nd Sale (April 1, 1932), Adams discovered lot 1302
offered a copy of Numisgraphics, with a brief, but significant
description: “Quarto—Pages Loose.”
All of the regular issue copies of Numisgraphics are octavo in
size while a quarto book is considerably larger; about the same height
and depth as an encyclopedia volume (and about the same size as the
“royal octavo” that Attinelli described in the Idell sale).
So Elder was selling one of those 10 large paper copies. The
notation that the pages were loose probably meant that they were
unbound. Adams’ find proves that at least one of the large paper
copies of Numisgraphics survived 54 years after the Idell auction.
But the great mystery remains: Where are these large paper copies
today? How could every example vanish? And who will be the first
collector to make headlines by unearthing one?
JOEL J. OROSZ is a charter member of the Numismatic Bibliomania
Society and co-author of The Secret History of the First U.S.
Mint. He can be reached at Joeljorosz@gmail.com.