An error in diagnosis

Cent 'variety' result of alteration
By
Published : 08/07/13
Text Size

In the May 20 installment of this column, I featured a 2002-D Lincoln cent with what appeared to be multiple extra columns in the fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth bays of the Lincoln Memorial. After receiving the coin back from me, the owner submitted the coin to ANACS for encapsulation as a die variety.

The good folks at ANACS were quick to pick up on the fact that it was actually an altered coin, the handiwork of someone with way too much time on their hands. The owner of the coin, who I must note is not the person who altered the coin, also sent the coin to error expert Mike Diamond, who writes the “Collectors’ Clearinghouse” column for Coin World. Diamond verified the findings of ANACS and the “variety” has been removed from my listings. It just goes to show that we die variety “specialists” are human and make mistakes every now and then.

Roosevelt dimes dominate the coins to illustrate this time out. Paul Funaiole submitted a 1947-S/D Roosevelt dime, which has an S Mint mark punched over a D Mint mark. Known as an “over Mint mark variety” (OMM), I have this one listed as 1947-S 10¢ WOMM-001. It is illustrated in The Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties where it is listed as FS-10-1947S-501 (013).

Two different varieties of 1947-S/D dimes are known. Albert B. Raddi submitted the second variety for comparison purposes. The shapes of the S Mint marks have subtle differences, but more importantly, more of the upper right curve of the D can be seen on the second variety. I list this one as 1947-S 10¢ WOMM-002 while The Cherrypickers’ Guide lists it as FS-10-1947S-502 (012).

Todd Henson submitted a 1970-D Roosevelt dime with a nice doubled die reverse that is listed in my files as 1970-D 10¢ WDDR-003. Nice doubling shows on STATES OF AMERICA, UNUM, DIME, the flames at the top of the fasces and the upper right olive leaves.

The three Roosevelt dime varieties are further proof that great varieties can still be found with a little searching!

John Wexler is a renowned numismatic researcher and author on error coins and die varieties.

You are signed in as:null

Please sign in or join to share your thoughts on this story

No comments yet