Among the more challenging areas of Morgan dollar variety
collecting are the Philadelphia Mint issues of 1878.
One of the more elusive pieces is the VAM-186A 1878 Morgan dollar.
The marriage was discovered by Clayton Christiansen in March 2006 and
is described in detail in the 1878 P 7 Tail Feather Morgan Dollar
Attribution Guide by Leroy Van Allen.
Attributing an 1878 Morgan dollar begins with the reverse. This
particular die is from a later stage of the Reverse of 1878 hub. The
eagle has a flattened, slightly concave breast, arrow feathers are
parallel, the end of the center arrow shaft is broken — commonly
referred to as a short nock — and the cross arm on the R of TRUST is broken.
The exact working reverse die may be identified by the diagonally
oriented parallel lines that fill the opening inside the wreath bow.
The obverse features a broken point on the fourth right star and a
spike above the upper eyelid. The listing notes some raised metal
inside the loops of the first digit 8, but this feature can be
extremely difficult to see on even lightly circulated examples.
Caution should be exercised with these obverse markers as other
working dies have very similar features. It is important to take note
of other obverse characteristics unique to this die. A pair of small
gouges resembling dots appear at the rear of the lower eyelid. Inside
Liberty’s mouth a pair of strong vertical gouges should be present.
Patterns of die polishing lines appear in the lower hair.
One of the best places to look is directly above the formation
that has acquired the nickname “the bear claw.” Whether you think this
large deeply forked clump of hair resembles a type of pastry or ursine
weaponry, the gaps around it are protected from wear and often hide
almost signature-like die lines.
Look above the “claws” for a pair of intersecting lines that looks
like a laterally elongated X with a tiny dot at the junction. It is
unique to this obverse and the only known use was in this marriage.
John Roberts is director of attribution services for ANACS. He is
a longtime collector of Morgan dollar varieties and is considered an
expert in attributing Morgan varieties.