The U.S. Mint has been reaching out to at least one foreign mint
with expertise in the production of a convex/concave coin as it
prepares its own similar issues for the 2014 National Baseball Hall of
Fame coin program.
Tom Jurkowsky, director of the U.S. Mint’s Office of Public
Affairs, said March 21 that U.S. Mint technical personnel had an
extensive group discussion with a senior member of the Perth Mint’s
technical staff in Australia at the start of the program to establish
project parameters. The meeting was held as part of the research and
development for the three-coin commemorative program, he said.
These parameters, according to Jurkowsky, include coin fill
issues, height of relief limitations, potential Proof polishing
issues, die life expectations and other technical issues.
Jurkowsky said that the Perth Mint representative acted as an
intermediary with the Royal Australian Mint, which produced a
convex/concave 2012 silver $5 coin commemorating the Crux
constellation, otherwise known as the Southern Cross.
The enabling legislation for the National Baseball Hall of Fame
coins — Public Law 112-152 — calls for the gold $5 half eagle and
silver dollar to be struck with dies resulting in the common obverse
being concave and the common reverse being convex.
The copper-nickel clad half dollar in the program will be struck
with normal dies that will not exhibit the convex/concave contour, as
per the law.
Public Law 112-152 requires that the half eagle and silver dollar
“should be produced in a fashion similar to the 2009 International
Year of Astronomy coins issued by Monnaie de Paris, the French Mint,
so that the reverse of the coin is convex to more closely resemble a
baseball and the obverse concave, providing a more dramatic display of
the obverse design chosen pursuant to section 4(c).”
Section 4(c) requires a design competition for which a common
obverse design will be selected by the Treasury secretary for all
The 2009 French �200 gold and �10 silver International Year of
Astronomy coins are concave on the obverse and convex on the reverse.
For the 2012 Australian silver $5 coin, the obverse bearing Queen
Elizabeth II’s effigy is convex while the reverse is concave.
U.S. Mint officials have not disclosed whether they have yet
consulted Monnaies de Paris officials as part of the research and
development process or if they plan to do so.
Research and development on the baseball coins is unprecedented in
recent Mint history, according to Jurkowsky.
Extensive development was undertaken on the concave/convex coins,
Jurkowsky said, to prove out the following:
➤ Production hubbing parameters.
➤ Height of relief limits.
➤ Milling, turning, and grinding operations.
➤ Coinability issues.
➤ Laser frosting and Proof polishing (for Proof coins).
➤ Proof and Uncirculated test strikes.
“Due to the project’s high visibility, anticipated volumes,
coupled with the extreme technical challenges, we elected to do
complete test coin development in all three alloys — gold, silver, and
clad,” Jurkowsky said.
“This included development of representative nonsense artwork,
specialized milling, turning and grinding operations, extensive
hubbing tests on our R&D [research and development] press, full
Proof polishing and laser frosting to familiarize Mint production
staff with these unique dies, and complete research and test coin
strikes,” Jurkowsky said.
Coin World has asked for images depicting the concave/convex
elements of the dies as well as the resultant text strikes.
“Nonsense” artwork is used exclusively for test strikes. The
nonsense designs often feature elements that are similar in position
and size to the actual designs used on coinage.
The U.S. Mint has had some experience with convex/concave issues
related to numismatic products.
The congressional gold medal authorized for Major League
Baseball’s Roberto Clemente in 1973 and the bronze duplicates sold by
the Mint to the general public are convex on both obverse and reverse. ■