Clamshell splits, clamshell separations are unrelated errors

By
Published : 01/19/13
Text Size

Coins and planchets that split along the horizontal plane are often lumped into a single category, the “clamshell split.”

However, this term should really be restricted to solid-alloy coins like cents, 5-cent coins and silver-alloy coins minted before the 1965 compositional change. In the case of clad-composition coins, the proper term should be “clamshell separation.”

While clamshell splits and clamshell separations are similar in appearance, these two planchet errors arise from entirely different causes.

A clamshell split is an alloy error in which a planchet or coin cleaves along the horizontal plane. The illustrated 1945-P Jefferson, Wartime Alloy 5-cent coin is a representative example. Many splits of this nature are thought to be caused by the presence of contaminants in the alloy.

Inadequate mixing of metals

A horizontal split can also be caused by an inadequate mixing of the constituent metals. This can leave a zone of weakness at the boundary between layers containing different proportions of metals. Wartime Alloy 5-cent coins — composed of 56 percent copper, 35 percent nickel and 9 percent manganese — are especially prone to clamshell splits and assorted types of “lamination” errors. The illustrated specimen clearly shows a poorly mixed alloy. The surface is marked by numerous lamination cracks and missing lamination flakes.

More than one plane of weakness can occasionally develop in a solid alloy coin. The illustrated 1944-P Jefferson 5-cent coin shows a double clamshell split on the edge.

When a split extends completely across a planchet, the two halves go their separate ways. If one or both hemi-planchets eventually make their way into a coinage press, you end up with a “split-before-strike” error. If a coin splits into two halves after the strike, you then have a pair of “split-after-strike” errors.

Clamshell splits are closely related to clamshell lamination flaps, like that seen in the accompanying 1981 Lincoln cent. The only difference is the depth at which separation occurs. A clamshell split generally develops at a depth between one-third and one-half of the distance between one face and the opposite face. Clamshell lamination flaps form much closer to the surface and are therefore much thinner. Because it’s so thin, a lamination flap can bend and fold over (as in the illustrated example), while a clamshell split will break off if it’s folded up.

By definition, the line of cleavage in a clamshell split or clamshell lamination flap must extend in from the edge without emerging on either face. If the line of cleavage does invade the coin’s surface in the form of a crack, the clamshell label is dropped. The defect is instead referred to as a retained lamination flake.

As mentioned earlier, clamshell separations are the exclusive province of clad-composition coins. A clamshell separation is a bonding error — a failure of one clad layer to bond to the core. In the bonding process used for contemporary, circulation-quality dimes, quarter dollars and half dollars, two coils of thin copper-nickel clad strip are bonded to a thicker coil of pure copper strip. Bonding occurs well above the melting point of both copper and nickel, as the three strips are forced together under enormous pressure between two rollers.

If pressure is inadequate, or if the facing surfaces of adjacent strips are not meticulously cleaned, a secure bond may not form. Once the blank is punched out, the poorly bonded clad layer can separate before or after the strike. A partial separation is the same thing as a clamshell separation. A typical example is shown here in a 1965 Roosevelt dime.

When a bond fails completely on a planchet, the clad layer assumes an independent existence. If it manages to reach a coinage press, it will emerge as a “struck clad layer.”

If a clad layer separates after the strike, it is also often called a struck clad layer. However, it would be more appropriately classified as a “separation-after-strike” error.

On very rare occasions a copper core will split along the horizontal plane, creating a “split core” error. Since the split occurs within a zone of solid metal, these kinds of errors are rightfully classified alongside clamshell splits and split planchet errors.

Coin World’s Collectors’ Clearinghouse department does not accept coins or other items for examination without prior permission from News Editor William T. Gibbs. Materials sent to Clearinghouse without prior permission will be returned unexamined. Please address all Clearinghouse inquiries to cweditor@coinworld.com or to 800-673-8311, Ext. 172.

You are signed in as:null

Please sign in or join to share your thoughts on this story

No comments yet