When dies strike each other without an intervening planchet, a
portion of the design will be coined into the opposing face. With
multiple clashing strikes, unusual added features can result. While
this sort of oddity may be difficult to understand at first glance,
its strangeness is its appeal.
In September 2003, Brian Raines discovered a 1902-O Morgan dollar
with some truly puzzling features. It was listed as VAM-26A by Leroy
Van Allen in New VAM Varieties of Morgan & Peace Dollars.
It is also an integral part of the set presented by Mark Kimpton
in his work, Elite Clashed Morgan Dollars. The die marriage appears to
have clashed at least four times in a single failure-to-feed event.
There was slight die rotation from the onset, causing the G from GOD
to be partially impressed in front of Liberty’s neck.
When dies are aligned normally, a partial outline of the letter N
from IN would be transferred. Clashing has a tendency to loosen and
move the dies as well. This effect can be seen in the slight offset in
the clash marks that pass from the wing edge through the G of GOD.
This can also create a clash mark of a clash mark, a counterclash.
On the VAM-26A variety, several areas display this unusual feature
of shallow localized doubling. On the obverse, a long section follows
the profile in front of Liberty’s eye. Additionally, a short section
of the outline of the neck transferred back above the partial G clash.
The reverse features an “extra”leaf tip opposite the NI of UNITED.
Strong clashing damages dies, and sometimes this can cause odd
depressions. These are the elongated rounded lumps in the coin’s
surface that VAM collectors have come to refer to as “ovaloids.” A
dramatic free standing one appears in front of Liberty’s eye and an
attached partial lump on an inner leaf tip opposite the left stand of
the N in UNITED.
The VAM-26A 1902-O Morgan dollar variety commands a staggering
premium when encountered and appears to be a significant rarity. Only
five examples are represented in the Society of Silver Dollar
John Roberts is director of attribution services for ANACS. He is
a longtime collector of Morgan dollar varieties and is considered an
expert in attributing Morgan varieties.