Auction offers space-flown medals from Apollo astronaut

Firm auctioning medals from Apollo 15 commander David R. Scott
Published : 11/09/12
Text Size

Some people go to great lengths to build a collection, but sometimes a collection features items that have traveled great lengths.

Twelve different silver medals from the collection of Apollo astronaut David R. Scott are being offered in RR Auction’s online space and aviation auction. Online bidding opens Nov. 15 and ends Nov. 29.

Most of the medals in the auction have made the nearly half-million-mile round trip from the Earth to the Moon and back. The medals are the numismatic highlights of the auction, and include an very rare Apollo 17 medal, an Apollo 11 medal and a medal marking the Apollo 15 mission commanded by Scott.

Scott had three flights into space, the last of which was the Apollo 15 mission, which provided the first extended scientific exploration of the moon.

The medals in the sale are from a series known to collectors as Robbins medallions.

Robbins medallions

Beginning with the first manned Apollo flight, Apollo 7, mission crew members contracted with the Robbins Co. of Attleboro, Mass., to create a series of gold and silver medals. The Robbins medals were ordered and paid for by NASA crew and staff, who were allowed to buy medals for any mission, regardless of their participation in the mission. A small number of each Robbins medal was placed aboard the Apollo spacecraft during a mission; the number flown aboard the spacecraft for any mission was limited.

Apollo missions carried between three and seven 14-karat gold medals per flight, and anywhere from 80 to 450 silver medals were “space flown” per mission, according to Howard Weinberger, author of two books on the Robbins medallions.

The silver medals remained in astronauts’ personal preference kits in the command module during the flights. However, on the lunar landing missions, the gold medals were taken to the lunar surface, according to Weinberger.

Still, with a celestial history, the silver medals are very popular, with those from the famed Apollo 11 mission and the final Apollo mission, when fewer medals were flown than on earlier missions, among the most desirable.

If collectors were to follow a few general succinct “rules” for collecting the Robbins medals, they would be — (1) a medal that has been flown into space is better than an unflown medal, (2) those from the collections of astronauts are worth more than those owned by other NASA staff, and (3) those medals that are from the crew members who flew aboard the specific mission commemorated on the medal usually are the most desirable.

Apollo 17 medal

Bobby Livingston, vice president of RR Auctions, expects the collection’s Apollo 17 silver medal to realize between $30,000 and $35,000 in the firm’s fourth space and aviation auction.

Scott’s Apollo 17 medal is serial numbered “F15,” the number being a reference to the Apollo 15 mission, which Scott commanded. Beginning with the Apollo 17 medals, an F was added to the serial number to distinguish the flown medals from those that were not flown. Perhaps as few as 80 silver medals were flown on the Apollo 17 mission, from the 300 total mintage, according to the auction firm.

The medal for the flight features a raised design of the Apollo 17 mission insignia on the obverse. The reverse features the minted inscription AMERICA-CHALLENGER APOLLO XVII, with separate dates representing the launch date, moon landing date and return date hand-engraved into spaces reserved for the information.

Scott’s Apollo 17 medal is graded Mint State 67 by Numismatic Guaranty Corp.

Apollo 15 medal

The obverse of the medal for the Apollo 15 flight shows the mission insignia while the reverse features inscriptions, including MAN’S FLIGHT THROUGH LIFE IS SUSTAINED BY THE POWER OF HIS KNOWLEDGE, along with hand-engraving of the launch, moon landing and return dates.

Because of a designer error on the reverse, two different medals were produced for this mission, and Scott’s collection contained one of each. The name of the landing spot, the Apennines Mountains, was misspelled as Appeninnes on the reverse of the original medals, in the fields adjacent to the space for the landing date. Medals with the correct spelling were produced, but only after completion of the mission.

Because of the misspelling and spacecraft weight concerns, the number of flown silver medals on the mission was limited to 127 pieces, with 177 pieces held back.

Post-mission production of corrected medals allowed the minter to do something special in their production. During the mission, Scott carried aboard in his personal preference kit a silver ingot from the 1715 Spanish Plate Fleet. Upon the crew’s return, the Robbins company melted the 177 unflown medals, added the silver from the ingot and struck 177 new medals from new planchets. These new medals thus have the corrected spelling and incorporate the flown Spanish silver (which had a higher fineness than the .925 fine silver in the other medals).

Scott’s flown medal in the auction, serial numbered 25, is graded MS-67 by NGC and has an estimate of $6,000 to $8,000.

Apollo 11 mission medal

Perhaps the most famous mission was the Apollo 11 mission, which landed a human on the Moon for the first time.

The mission insignia graces the obverse of the Apollo 11 medal. The surnames of astronauts Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldrin and Michael Collins, along with the hand-engraved launch, landing and return dates, appear on the reverse.

Scott’s medal, serial numbered 231, is in Mint State condition and is housed in its original numbered case. It has an estimate of $25,000 to $30,000.

View the auction at ■

You are signed in as:null

Please sign in or join to share your thoughts on this story

No comments yet