It is only natural that some of the most dramatic Morgan dollar
varieties were discovered by pioneers in the field.
Many of these finds were uncovered when dedicated collectors first
began to look at their coins a little closer. Their work continues to
serve as an anchor for most of the research that has followed.
In September 1973, legendary collector and author Bill Fivaz
encountered an 1887 Morgan dollar with a strongly repunched date that
was previously unknown.
The variety became VAM-5 when published in the subsequent edition
of Comprehensive Catalog and Encyclopedia of Morgan & Peace
Dollars by Leroy Van Allen and A. George Mallis.
Some interesting study on this variety can be found in Dollar
Varieties and Errors Scrapbook compiled by Van Allen from the
pre-merger Numismatic Error Collectors of America publication
Errorscope. While the coin can be somewhat difficult to locate, the
anthology is of greater rarity.
The VAM-5 1887 Morgan dollar is noteworthy for its strongly
During this period of Morgan dollar production, the date was sunk
into the individual working dies by several blows from a four-digit
punch. Misalignment between blows caused localized doubling of the
date. On this die, the shift was angular.
Close examination is required to see traces of this misalignment
on the digits 18. However, the secondary impressions seen on the
digits 87 are bold to a numismatist experienced in die varieties.
The marriage had a fairly long production run and late die stage
examples are known, although they not as desirable as early die stage coins.
The unique characteristics of the date are far more difficult to
see on worn coins or coins from worn dies, but secondary die markers
may confirm attributions.
Several hundred examples are known and it is typically found in
Mint State 62 or MS-63 condition.
Examples can be located with the exercise of a modest degree of patience.
John Roberts is director of attribution services for ANACS. He is
a longtime collector of Morgan dollar varieties and is considered an
expert in attributing Morgan varieties.