Several years ago the emphasis in most numismatic publications
switched from using black and white images to color images.
Die variety specialists maintaining listings on these varieties
have since been trying to replace their older images with color images.
Recently, coin dealer Garland Lawson graciously sent two different
Proof 1971-S Lincoln, Doubled Die Obverse cent varieties to assist
with my color image quest.
Both are major varieties worthy of another look.
The first is listed in my files as 1971-S 1¢ Pr WDDO-001. The
April 16, 1975, issue of Coin World, first reported the variety and
cites coin dealer Harry Forman as the person who discovered it. Bold
doubling shows on LIBERTY and the letters of IN GOD WE TRUST. The
spread decreases from left to right on these letters. Strong doubling
shows on the date.
This variety is featured in The Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare
Die Varieties, listed as FS-01-1971S-101 (032). It is extremely
rare with an estimated mintage of 3,000 coins. That is the die life of
Proof Lincoln cent dies.
The other variety Mr. Lawson submitted is listed in my files as
1971-S 1¢ Pr WDDO-002. It was discovered by yours truly in 1982 and
was first reported in the April 30, 1982, issue of Error-Variety News
magazine when I was still editor and co-owner of that publication.
This variety also has bold doubling to LIBERTY and IN GOD WE
TRUST, but little doubling on the date. The spread on IN GOD WE TRUST
does not decrease from left to right as it does on the previous
variety. It is listed in The Cherrypickers’ Guide as FS-01-1971S-102
(033) and also has an estimated mintage of 3,000.
The untrained eye may have difficulty telling the varieties apart
since the boldest doubling on LIBERTY is very similar on both
varieties. The key is the word WE. On WDDO-001, the doubling is
minimal while it is much bolder on WDDO-002.
Check your 1971-S Proof sets. You may have a pleasant surprise
waiting for you!
John Wexler is a renowned numismatic researcher and author on
error coins and die varieties.