What has been reported as the seventh known example of the NC-3
1795 Liberty Cap, Plain Edge cent was certified June 6 by ANACS.
ANACS Senior Numismatist Michael Fahey said the grading service
assigned the grade of Fair 2 to the new discovery. All of the other
six known examples of the variety are heavily circulated.
Fahey said the coin was delivered to ANACS at the May 31 to June 2
Long Beach Coin, Stamp & Collectibles Expo in Long Beach, Calif.,
where he confirmed the variety attribution. The new discovery was
submitted to ANACS as a possible Sheldon 77 variety or NC-3 variety by
New Hampshire dealer Jim Carr, on behalf of Massachusetts collector
The new discovery was further confirmed by large cent specialists
Tom Reynolds, Early American Coin Gallery LLC, from Omaha, Neb., and
Jack Beymer, from Jack H. Beymer, Santa Rosa, Calif.
Beymer is responsible for discovering the first example of the
variety, cataloged as NC-3 in Penny Whimsy by William H. Sheldon.
Beymer discovered the Basal State 1 piece on April 5, 1980, in a group
of coins he purchased at a Washington, D.C., show in July 1979.
The NC variety designation stands for “noncollectible.” Sheldon’s
grading system differentiates between “collectible” and
“noncollectible” varieties. At the time the Sheldon cataloging system
was devised, a known die pairing represented by just one to three
examples was assigned an NC attribution rather than a specific Sheldon
number preceded by the letter S because Sheldon considered the variety
to be so rare as to be “noncollectible.” Today, the NC designation has
been expanded to encompass varieties with fewer than 10 examples known
Diagnostics for the NC-3 1795 Liberty Cap, Plain Edge cent
indicate the reverse die was used exclusively for the NC-3 variety.
According to United States Large Cents 1795-1797 by William C. Noyes,
the reverse is distinguished by two leaves directly under the T of
CENT. Two leaves are present left of the C in CENT, extending above
the center of C. There is a triple leaf at CA of AMERICA.
The obverse die for the NC-3 variety was also used for the Sheldon
76a, 76b and 77 varieties. It is characterized by diagnostics showing
about half of the top of the 5 embedded in the bust of Liberty,
according to Noyes.
Another diagnostic involves the pole supporting the Liberty cap.
“The pole is close to the bust, but does not touch,” according to
Noyes. “The juncture of hair and forehead is just below the right foot
of [the] T. LIB lower than RTY. L almost touches the cap.
Process of elimination
Fahey said in an email to Coin World that he made his NC-3
determination based on a process of elimination.
“The coin is a ... thin planchet ... variety, which limits it to
S-76B, S-77, S-78, S-79 (the ultra rare Reeded Edge variety), S-80
(one of the ‘Jefferson Head’ varieties), NC-2 and NC-3,” Fahey said.
“The position of the letters in LIBERTY above the head eliminates S-78
and S-79, and the Jefferson Head is very different in style, leaving
only Obverse 3, which was used for S-76B, S-77 and NC-3.
“On the reverse, the word CENT is close to the ribbon bow,
eliminating S-76B. The two long vertical leaves to the left of the ‘C’
in CENT eliminates S-77, which has a 3 leaf cluster in a different
position to the left of C.
“The position of the top of the 5 in the date, the position of
LIBERTY, and location of CENT, and the leaves next to the C in CENT
are the key areas to identify the variety. Other diagnostics are not
as easily seen due to the heavy wear the coin has received.”
Reynolds refers to the NC-3 cent as a “mystery” variety, since all
known examples are heavily circulated and show no obverse or reverse
evidence of die failure. Reynolds said one would expect a higher grade
example to have surfaced.
Exclusive of McDermott’s coin, three of the remaining six 1795
NC-3 cents are Fair 2, one is About Good 3 and one Basal State 1,
based on the 70-point Sheldon Grading Scale, with 70 considered a
The new discovery is likely to drop the rarity of the variety from
an R-7+ to R-7, Reynolds said. Rarity 7 equates to “Extremely Rare (4
to 12),” according to Penny Whimsy.
Beymer could not be reached for comment.
New Hampshire dealer Carr, who has been a collector for 50 years
and a dealer for more than 40 of them, said McDermott asked him to
attribute the large cent he had acquired some time ago from among a
group of U.S. coins purchased in a small, long-time collection.
Carr, an advanced collector of large cents, said despite the
coin’s heavy wear, he had no trouble identifying the obverse die used
to strike the coin. However, he said he spent a little more time
inspecting the reverse, the diagnostics for which roused his
suspicions as possibly another NC-3 find.
Carr said June 6 he had not yet spoken with McDermott to inform
him of the confirmation of the NC-3 variety.
“I’m thrilled for him,” Carr said of McDermott, who sometimes
assists him at coin shows and sells some of his own purchases. “It’s
nice to see him catch a nice coin.”
Carr said he plans to bring the ANACS-certified coin with him when
he meets McDermott at the Whitman Baltimore Coin and Collectibles Expo
June 28 to July 1.
An example of the variety has appeared at auction twice since
2005, both involving the same coin.
The coin appeared in Heritage Auctions’ January 2005 sale of the
Wes Rasmussen Collection, at which the piece sold for $8,625, which
included the 15 percent buyer’s fee.
The coin was next offered as part of the Dan Holmes Collection,
Part I auction in September 2009 by Ira & Larry Goldberg,
Auctioneers, where it sold for $8,050, including the 15 percent
buyer’s fee. The coin, which had previously certified Good 6 Details,
Corroded, by ANACS, had been broken out of the holder for the Holmes