A compelling but little-discussed auction trade occurred on April
19 during Heritage Auctions’ sale in conjunction with the Central
States Numismatic Society convention when a Proof 1990-S Washington,
Doubled Die Obverse quarter dollar graded Proof 70 Deep Cameo traded
A regular Proof 1990-S quarter dollar trades for less than $50 in
the highest grade of Proof 70.
Most doubled dies have a pick-up point (an area where the doubling
is most prominent) that is used to identify the variety.
When the 1990-S Doubled Die Obverse quarter dollar was discovered
by Jim Carr, he noted that its pick-up point was different. The
doubling is most prominent on the Mint mark, a dramatically doubled
“S.” Historically, Mint marks were added to dies after they were
impressed by the hub. In the mid-1980s Mint marks were added to the
hub, and this coin was the first doubled die to clearly show a doubled
die Mint mark.
Proof coins are carefully scrutinized by the U.S. Mint and any
Proof coin irregularity captures the interest of collectors.
On average, only about 2,500 coins are struck from a single Proof
die. In 1990, 3.3 million Proof sets and Prestige Proof sets were
sold, and just 2,500 of these coins were scattered among them. A
collector has less than a 1-in-1,300 chance of finding a 1990-S
Doubled Die Obverse quarter dollar in a Proof set.
Even given those long odds, many numismatists believe that the
1990-S Doubled Die Obverse quarter dollar is still far scarcer than it
should be. After all, the 1990-S Proof set is the single most
thoroughly examined Proof set of the modern era.
Not only can the 1990-S Doubled Die Obverse quarter dollar variety
be found in the 1990-S sets, but two other great varieties can be
found: the 1990-S Lincoln, No S cent (200+ known) — which brings
almost $20,000 in the highest grades — and the 1990-S Jefferson,
Doubled Die Obverse 5-cent coin (40+ known).
Fewer than 20 examples of the 1990-S Doubled Die Obverse quarter
dollars are known and only 15 have been graded by Numismatic Guaranty
Corp. and Professional Coin Grading Service combined. NGC has
certified four, the finest grading Proof 69 Ultra Cameo. PCGS has
graded 11; the finest is the lone Proof 70 Deep Cameo that Heritage
sold in April for a record price.
A Proof 68 Ultra Cameo example can still be purchased for less
than $500. Proof 69 Ultra Cameo examples trade for over $1,000. As the
finest example of this variety is pushing the $5,000 mark, here is a
clear message to collectors: Check your 1990-S Proof sets and Prestige
Scott schechter is a grader at NGC and co-author of 100 Greatest
U.S. Modern Coins. He can be reached by email directed to him at firstname.lastname@example.org.