It’s apparent that designs for most of the America the Beautiful
quarter dollars issued to date are engraved copies of photographs of
popular attractions from the various nature sites being honored on the coins.
While that may work OK for national parks, it presents a real
disconnect for sites that have important ties to our nation’s history.
The three designs advanced by the United States Mint for Ohio’s
2013 quarter dollar, which is supposed to honor Perry’s Victory and
International Peace Memorial, are a good example of the disconnect.
“Perry’s Victory” refers to Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry and the
United States naval victory on Sept. 10, 1813, when he led nine small
ships to defeat a British squadron of six large vessels in the Battle
of Lake Erie. The victory proved to be a turning point in the War of
1812 and secured the Northwest Territory for the United States as well
as opening up critical supply lines.
The International Peace Memorial refers to a 352-foot Doric column
erected on South Bass Island at Put-in-Bay on Lake Erie that was
supervised by a multi-state commission from 1912 to 1915. The
monument’s intent was “to inculcate the lessons of international peace
by arbitration and disarmament.” (The remains of three American and
British officers are interred under the stone floor of the monument.)
From the observation deck of the column one can look out onto Lake
Erie and imagine the 1813 battle scene or merely view islands in Lake
Erie and the shorelines of Ohio, Michigan and Ontario, Canada.
It’s obvious the National Park Service liaison person designated
to assist the U.S. Mint with design concepts provided photographs of
the memorial column and one from inside the visitor’s center, because
that’s exactly what the Mint’s artist rendered for the design
concepts: A statue of Perry inside the visitor’s center with the
memorial column in view through a window (complete with lattice), a
wide-angle view of the column on South Bass Island, and a close-up of
the column’s observation deck, with U.S., British and Canadian flags
prominent on both column designs.
We agree with the Commission of Fine Arts. The three designs
advanced by the Mint just don’t work. They are too busy for the small
canvas of a quarter dollar and they do not connect to the only legend,
“Perry’s Victory,” at the top of the design, the subject being honored.
The people of Ohio are very aware of Perry’s historic role. When
some 40,000 residents of the Buckeye State offered ideas for their
2002 State quarter dollar design, “Perry’s Victory on Lake Erie” was
among the six finalists. In fact, a coin design based on the famous
painting by Ohio native William Henry Powell was developed for the
online voting, and the rights are owned by the state of Ohio. (No
doubt, Ohio’s governor would make the design available to the Mint for
free for use on a new quarter dollar.)
If Mint artists insist on creating their own rendition, one of
Powell’s oil paintings of the famous naval battle hangs in the Senate
wing of the U.S. Capitol. The other has a place of honor in the
rotunda of the Ohio Statehouse in Columbus. So there’s easy access to
see the paintings in the flesh. Plus images of both paintings are
available on the Internet.
The U.S. Mint should go back to the drawing boards. Perry’s
victory was an important event in U.S. history and it is a worthy
subject to commemorate on this coin. There’s plenty of time. It just
takes a “can do” attitude and a willingness to create good coin