Old coin auction catalogs are a joy to read. Most fun of all is how
19th century coin dealers used their catalogs as blunt instruments to
bludgeon their competitors. Today, libelous statements would land the
writer in court, but in the 1800s, the victim would just hit back in
his next catalog.
The heavyweight champion of 19th century name-calling was Ebenezer
Locke Mason, an early coin dealer in — ironically enough — the City of
Brotherly Love, Philadelphia. Here is some vintage Ebenezer, accusing
fellow Pennsylvanian Charles Steigerwalt of plagiarism: “Down on your
marrow bones, Stigey, and beg forgiveness; or pay us for … your cool
impudence in filching our brains, and denying the fact.”
Old Eb was uncharitable about every error made by colleagues.
Take, for example, his contempt for New York’s David Proskey, for his
“… ignorance in asserting in positive terms that the ‘1838 half
dollar, O Mint, is a pattern piece.’ ”
Mason’s targets suffered, but rarely in silence. Edward Cogan, the
self-styled “Father of the Coin Trade” in America, was publicly
critical of Mason’s grading in the latter’s J. Colvin Randall auction
of Oct. 28 to 29, 1868. Eb returned fire, prompting Cogan to publish
an open letter in which he called Mason’s response “contemptible,
unintelligible, untruthful twaddle.”
Cogan was the silverback male among coin dealers, and Mason
prudently decided that he had nothing to gain from an “Ed versus Eb”
feud, so he chose not to reply.
None of Mason’s opponents counterpunched as hard as Charles
Chaplin, a mouthpiece for Boston’s Trifet Company. Writing in
Trifet’s American Stamp Mercury and Numismatist, Chaplin
dissed and dismissed Ebenezer as “amusingly stupid,” and most
memorably, as “one of the high-pressure kind of human gas bags.” This
sly allusion to Mason’s service in the Army of the Potomac’s Balloon
Corps surely evoked the vision of him as a giant bladder of hot air.
Chaplin was unkind, but not inaccurate, for Eb was an odd duck. He
chronicled his strange doings in a series of numismatic magazines that
he published throughout his career, along with ads for coins and
airings of his current grudges. My favorite is the tale of his
journeying to Boston in December 1871, dropping in, unannounced — on
Christmas morning! — at the homes of flabbergasted numismatists like
author S.S. Crosby and dealer W. Elliot Woodward. Eb complained that
Woodward was “too busy with family presents to devote any time to coin matters”!
If you’d enjoy reading Mason’s ramblings and slanderings, you are
in luck. Numismatic booksellers frequently offer, at reasonable
prices, copies of the 34 catalogs Mason produced during his 30-year
numismatic career. Issues of the six different coin magazines that
Mason published are rarer, and therefore pricier, but happily, the
numismatic bookseller Charles Davis has reprinted them all, in two
volumes, again reasonably priced. So it really is easy to see if Mason
won or lost more verbal jousts with his fellow coin dealers. Whether
you find old Eb amusing, or just “amusingly stupid,” you will be
fascinated by all of the “flying feathers” these publications contain.
JOEL J. OROSZ is a charter member of the Numismatic Bibliomania
Society and co-author of The Secret History of the First U.S.
Mint. He can be reached at Joeljorosz@gmail.com.