One of the beauties of coins and medals as collectibles is that
most are fairly easy to identify. As long as they’re legible and you
understand the language of the inscription, a coin or medal typically
says where it’s from, and who made it and when. This is perhaps one of
the appeals of our field. It offers sure things in a world that offers few.
One of the most fascinating medals of the Colonial era, however,
has befuddled numismatists for more than a century and a half.
Despite an inscription that includes a city, a date and even an
issuing authority, the rare Charleston Social Club medal still suffers
from something of an existential crisis. We don’t know what it is or
why it exists, only that it is historic and very rare.
The obverse of the distinctive oval medal depicts two apparently
microcephalic men in upper crust Colonial garb shaking hands beneath
the inscription vincti amicitia, or “bound in friendship.” The reverse
is simpler still, with just an inscription: social club instituted,
charles town south carolina, vi october mdcclxiii.
How could there be a riddle about a medal so clearly identified,
even down to the day of its issuance?
After years of research by various modern numismatists, no one has
ever found evidence of a “Charles Town Social Club.” Charleston,
founded in 1670, was one of the American Colonies’ richest urban
centers, its wealth built on the back of plantation slavery. Dozens of
various social clubs were founded by the glitterati of the day, from
the Charleston Jockey Club to the South Carolina Society to more
obscure organizations like the Kolf Baan Club, the Ugly Club, and the
Three Pace Club.
As early as 1856, Boston numismatist Jeremiah Colburn wrote to
antiquarians in Charleston trying to figure out which club produced
the medals, and he even managed to find the last surviving member of a
group called the Charles Town Social Club. No one knew a thing about
the medals. The trail has only gotten colder since.
We know they’re old. One has a provenance going back to the 1817
sale of the Thomas Brand Hollis Collection, sold after the collector’s
death in 1804.
Today, only three are thought to exist. The most recent sale of
one, by Stack’s in 2006, realized $57,500. Clearly, the mystery of the
medal isn’t holding back its value in the marketplace.
The wealthy members of the Charleston Social Club likely issued
the medal to secure their place in the august history of their town.
As it turns out, even such a concrete memento of their
organization wasn’t enough to keep the club from the dustbin of history.
John Kraljevich Jr. is an independent professional numismatist and
researcher specializing in early American coinage.