In a clever marketing move, Professional Coin Grading Service and
Numismatic Guaranty Corp. are grading and encapsulating 2011 American
Eagle silver bullion coins struck at the San Francisco Mint with
inserts stating that the coins were produced at San Francisco.
However, it raises the question — what premium, if any, should
collectors pay for a coin that looks indistinguishable from its West
Point Mint counterpart? None of the 2011 American Eagle silver bullion
coins struck at either facility bears the S or W Mint mark, and the
U.S. Mint has stated that the strikes from the San Francisco Mint will
be the same as those produced at the West Point Mint.
That grading services will designate only coins delivered to them
in sealed 500-coin boxes as originally received by the U.S. Mint’s
authorized purchasers harshly limits the public’s ability to certify
these coins themselves.
Any additional value that the market ascribes to these San
Francisco Mint coins comes from the original packaging, which is lost
Another coin with a value that is strongly dependent on its
original packaging is the “Cheerios” 2000 Lincoln cent. In 2000,
Cheerios included 10 million 2000 Lincoln cents in special blister
packaging with its cereal. These coins are normal — identical to the
“regular” issues but for the packaging.
PCGS and NGC will both identify coins coming from the Cheerios
promotion on the label, with PCGS calling it a “minor variety.” The
cents rose to fame when it was discovered that the majority of the
2000 Sacagawea golden dollars included in just 5,500 of the Cheerios
boxes featured a special reverse, commonly called the “Reverse of 1999.”
Cheerios cents sell for around $5 in original packaging, while a
non-Cheerios 2000 cent is worth little more than face value. In a slab
noting the Cheerios origin, they sell for slight premiums over
non-Cheerios cents, although most collectors do not view Cheerios
cents as anything special.
My colleague, Bill Gibbs, brought up an apt analogy to another
collectible field where packaging matters: originally packaged Hot
Wheels miniature model cars. While the No. 225 Hot Wheels from the
2002 series, a mostly red ’57 Chevy, is worth around $3 when it is
loose, it is valued at $225 when packaged singularly in its original
card, since the majority of the cars were released as part of an
extremely limited number of sets. Same car, yet packaging makes one
substantially more valuable. Yet, once removed from its package, its
value returns to normal.
Next month this column will look at a similar phenomenon: value
created by the PCGS First Strike and NGC Early Release designation program.
Steven Roach is associate editor of Coin World. Email him