A unique silver bar from the American West realized $12,210 in a
May 1 auction in Minnesota.
The bar, described as a “discovery piece” by an expert in Western
Americana, is reportedly the first one cast from silver mined at the
Trade Dollar Mining and Milling Co. in Silver City, Idaho.
It contains more than 25 troy ounces of silver.
The face of the bar is inscribed first bar of the trade dollar
m&m. co. cast nov. 15, 1892 silver city idaho.
“It’s a heck of a piece of Americana,” said James Peterson, the
auctioneer of the Edina, Minn., auction house that carries his name
and that offered the lot.
“What a history that thing had! What are the chances of there ever
being another one like this?” Peterson said.
The item was found by the anonymous consigning family, inside a
safe deposit box, according to Peterson. The ingot was not from the
Dr. Frederick Raymond Jr. estate that comprised some 90 percent of the
400-plus lots in the auction, Peterson said, but was from a different source.
The back of the ingot bears inscriptions relating its weight as
25.3 ounces, with a composition of .003 fine gold and .979 fine silver.
The gold value was listed on the bar as $1.56, while the silver
was worth $24.76, as determined by assayer R.L. Euler, whose assay
mark appears on the ingot.
The Trade Dollar Mining and Milling Co. was incorporated in
Kentucky in July 1891, and by 1898 was headquartered in Pittsburgh,
according to an 1898 commercial directory from Owyhee County, Idaho,
home of Silver City.
One of the officers of the firm was Andrew W. Mellon, the philanthropist.
The company owned more than a dozen mines on the southern slope of
the Florida Mountains, according to the directory.
By the 1898 publication, the property ranked with the best paying
properties on the Pacific Coast, according to the directory, which
also noted that the Trade Dollar in 1897 “paid larger dividends than
any one mine in Cripple Creek [Colo.], according to published records
The sale price reflects a hammer price of $11,000 plus 11 percent
Fred Holabird of Holabird-Kagin Americana, geologist and expert in
western mining history, said he was the underbidder for the piece and
had no concerns about the authenticity of the “discovery piece,” a
heretofore unknown item.
“It’s a good piece,” he said.
In the recent past, Holabird has warned collectors about unrelated
purported western ingots that he believed to be recent counterfeits.
Peterson said that an anonymous collector of Americana from New
York state bought the bar and intends to hold it in his collection.
“It’s not for resale,” Peterson said. ■