Strongly clashed dies with letter transfer have been reported for
Morgan dollars for several decades. Many of these are well known and
A similar effect on Peace dollars has been noted on only a small
handful of examples. They are so elusive that they have yet to capture
In correspondence dated March 6, Leroy Van Allen credited Mark
Kimpton with the discovery of the new VAM-1BB 1924 Peace dollar. It
will be published in the 2012 edition of New VAM Varieties of
Morgan & Peace Dollars. Van Allen describes the variety as
“Clashed die with partial incuse ‘E’ from WE of obverse” and called
the find “amazing.”
Clash marks occur when a planchet fails to feed into the press.
The dies strike each other and portions of the opposing dies’ designs
are coined into their mates. Subsequent coins struck from the clashed
dies will show these marks. Clash marks vary in strength due to the
orientation of the dies within the press during the clashing strike.
Die wear and polishing are also factors. For this variety, a
portion of the letter e of we contacted the reverse die above the
eagle’s upper back leaving an impression that appears to pass under
the second ray from the top.
Naturally other strong clash marks are present on the reverse, but
curiously, the corresponding clashing found on the obverse is fairly
faint. The reverse die also features a small patch of pitting above
the do of dollar. The obverse is fairly nondescript beyond the faint
clash marks, but there is a thin die crack at the top of the Phrygian
cap under the r of liberty.
Like most new discoveries, it is difficult to estimate how rare it
might be. However, at least initially, the VAM-1BB appears to be very
elusive. It is challenging at best to assign a reasonable value for
the variety. It may take several years for more examples to help
establish a trading history. I can personally attest that the current
example will remain within the collection in which it now resides.
John Roberts is director of attribution services for ANACS. He is
a longtime collector of Morgan dollar varieties and is considered an
expert in attributing Morgan varieties.