While Professional Coin
Grading Service and Numismatic Guaranty Corp. are grading and
encapsulating 2014 to 2017 American Eagle silver bullion coin
production at the West Point, San Francisco and Philadelphia Mints,
PCGS won’t certify some coins until clarification can
be obtained from the U.S. Mint on its shipping box number system.
“For 2014–2017 boxes that have a sticker on the side that includes
the designation ‘WPM,’ PCGS believes that these [500-coin] boxes,
regardless of their serial number, originated in West Point,”
according to PCGS Vice President Mark Stephenson. “Therefore, at this
time, and until we receive further clarification from the U.S. Mint,
we will not be attributing such boxes to Philadelphia or San Francisco.”
Connect with Coin World:
up for our free eNewsletter
Like us on
us on Twitter
Acting upon the original documents provided to Coin
World by the U.S. Mint, in response to a Freedom of
Information Act (FOIA) request and published online, PCGS began to
grade, identify and encapsulate the bullion coins.
Another botched release from the United States
Mint: Inside Coin World:
The release of the Congratulations set adds to the narrative that
the U.S. Mint needs to overhaul its approach to limited-edition releases.
Coin World's FOIA request was filed in February, at the same
time that NGC independently sought the same information. The same
information in response to both requests was provided to both Coin
World and NGC, from which that Florida-based grading service developed its own grading label program for the coins.
PCGS explained in announcing its labeling program, “Until now, the
information about how many American silver Eagles were made in each of
the other branches has not been released to the public. Instead, the
Mint’s figures officially reflected the total mintage, and listed
those mintages as having been produced at West Point.
“However, the FOIA documents reveal a method of identifying where a
given box of silver Eagles was minted. Following this method, PCGS
will attribute coins from such boxes as having been produced at the
Branch Mint at which it was made.”
For example, an American Eagle silver bullion coin minted at the
Philadelphia Mint in 2015 would be attributed “2015-(P).”
Understanding the numbering system was key to enabling PCGS and NGC
to identify coins by Mint of origin, since none of the bullion coins
have Mint marks.
The “key” issue from the 2014 to 2017 period is the 2015 coin struck
at the Philadelphia Mint, with a mintage of 79,640 pieces, a tiny
fraction of the total in comparison to the nearly 47 million pieces
struck at the West Point Mint (none were struck for 2015 at the San
Based on the information in the Mint's response, owners of
Mint-sealed boxes of American Eagle silver bullion coins from 2014 to
2017 can find the box number, which is written in black marker, and
determine the specific Mint facility where the box and its contents originated.