Collectors should start paying more attention to any 1998 American
Eagle silver bullion coins in their collections. An example of the
coin has been found struck on a commemorative silver dollar planchet.
The wrong planchet error is the only example confirmed so far to
have been struck on a .900 fine silver planchet instead of the
intended .999 silver planchet. The coin is certified and graded Mint
State 68 by Professional Coin Grading Service.
The wrong planchet error is in the collection of Washington
collector Deb Biebesheimer.
The wrong planchet error is believed to have been struck at the
San Francisco Mint. That facility struck 1998 American Eagle silver
bullion coins as well as Proof and Uncirculated 1998 silver dollars
for the Robert F. Kennedy and Black Revolutionary War Patriots
programs. Both commemorative silver dollars were struck on .900 fine
commemorative silver dollar planchets.
Biebesheimer, who moved to the West Coast earlier this year from
New York, said she purchased the coin May 10 from Collectors Alliance
in Lakewood Township, N.J. The coin had already been certified as a
wrong planchet error when she purchased it.
She initially kept quiet about the purchase, and said she was “a
little paranoid about telling people I even had this pricey coin.”
Biebesheimer said she has since shed her jitters over acquiring the
coin and begun talking with other collectors about the coin.
“I find people are really interested,” Biebesheimer said. “I have
also done more in-depth research on error coins and have come to
realize how cool it is to have a coin where you can easily see the
errors and understand how they manifested during the manufacturing process.
“I want to be a good steward for this bit of history.”
Biebesheimer said she started collecting coins as a youth, but did
not get heavily into the hobby until several years ago, after she retired.
The foundation of her resurrected numismatic collecting habits
rested on about a dozen Morgan dollars her father had given her.
Biebesheimer said she expanded her Morgan dollar collection,
eventually branching out into other series, including American Eagles.
Wrong planchet error surfaces
Justin Duane, sales manager for Collectors Alliance, said Oct. 24
that he purchased the coin from another dealer who offered the
uncertified 1998 silver American Eagle to him during the May 9 to 11
American Numismatic Association National Money Show in New Orleans.
Duane did not disclose the name of the dealer from whom he purchased
the wrong planchet error nor the purchase price.
Duane said he did not know who discovered the wrong planchet error
as such, or when, nor how it came to be in the possession of the
After purchasing the wrong planchet error from the unnamed dealer,
Duane said he took the coin at the show to error coin specialist Fred
Weinberg from Fred Weinberg & Co., Encino, Calif.
Weinberg said he first noticed the coin was missing the customary
reeding on the edge. When he weighed the coin and it registered
between 26 and 27 grams, Weinberg said he knew the planchet was
originally intended for a commemorative silver dollar.
Weinberg, who is a PCGS consultant for attributing and
authenticating error coins, submitted the coin to PCGS for
certification on behalf of Collectors Alliance.
Once certified, the wrong planchet error was offered to
Biebesheimer, Duane said.
Differences between dollars
The PCGS grading insert for the wrong planchet error identifies
the weight at 26.7 grams.
The intended diameter of commemorative silver dollars is 1.5
inches (38.1 millimeters) and the weight legislated at 26.73 grams.
Those specifications are traditional and also apply to the
planchets used for striking Morgan dollars and Peace dollars.
In contrast, the American Eagle 1-ounce silver bullion coins
measure 40.6 millimeters in diameter and are intended to weigh 31.01 grams.
The difference in diameter between an American Eagle planchet and
a commemorative planchet explains the absence of edge reeding
(normally imparted by the edge collar die) for the 1998 wrong planchet
error, Weinberg said.
Silver American Eagle bullion coins do not have Mint marks, so for
older pieces from years when more than one facility struck the coins
during a calendar year, the origin cannot be identified.
From 1986 to 1987, American Eagle silver bullion coins were struck
exclusively at the San Francisco Mint. From 1988 to 1998 inclusive,
silver American Eagle bullion coins were struck at both the West Point
Mint and the San Francisco facility, according to U.S. Mint officials.
From 1999 to 2010 inclusive, silver American Eagle bullion coins
were struck exclusively at West Point.
From May 2011 to the present, silver American Eagle bullion coins
have been struck at both West Point and San Francisco.
The Philadelphia Mint has never produced any American Eagle silver
bullion coins, according to U.S. Mint officials. ■